Pizza Paradise in Williamsburg

Williamsburg, Virginia, is a goldmine for pizza lovers. Whether you’re after gluten-free options or authentic Italian slices, Williamsburg has got you covered.

Gluten-Free Goodies

If gluten is your nemesis but pizza is your love, Williamsburg has some stellar gluten-free options:

  • New York Deli & Pizza: They serve up gluten-free pizza, bread, buns, pita, and sandwiches. Safe and tasty, what more could you want? (Find Me Gluten Free).

  • Giuseppe’s Italian Restaurant: Craving more than just pizza? Giuseppe’s offers gluten-free pizza, desserts, and pasta. It’s a gluten-free haven (Find Me Gluten Free).

  • Sal’s By Victor: Known for their delicious gluten-free pizza and pasta, Sal’s is a must-visit for anyone with gluten sensitivities (Find Me Gluten Free).

  • Mellow Mushroom: This trendy pizza joint offers stone-baked gluten-free pizza with creative toppings. Their crusts and sauce are made with no additives or preservatives (Find Me Gluten Free).

  • Anna’s Brick Oven: With gluten-free pizza and pasta on the menu, Anna’s is perfect for those looking to indulge without the gluten (Find Me Gluten Free).

RestaurantGluten-Free Options
New York Deli & PizzaPizza, Bread/Buns, Pita, Sandwiches
Giuseppe’s Italian RestaurantPizza, Dessert, Pasta
Sal’s By VictorPizza, Pasta
Mellow MushroomPizza
Anna’s Brick OvenPizza, Pasta

Authentic Italian Flavors

If you’re craving a slice of Italy, Williamsburg has several pizzerias that will transport you straight to the streets of Rome:

  • Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano: Serving mouthwatering, authentic pizza from a family recipe, Antonio’s also offers a cauliflower crust pizza for gluten-free guests (Westgate Resorts).

  • Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza-Pasta: Known for its authentic brick-oven pizza with a light, crispy crust and a delicious array of toppings. They won the 2020 Best of Coastal Virginia Reader’s Choice Award.

  • Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta: This family-owned spot is celebrated for its authentic Italian cuisine and friendly service. They won the 2020 TripAdvisor Traveler’s Choice Award for their outstanding pizza.

RestaurantAuthentic Features
Antonio’s Ristorante ItalianoFamily Recipe, Cauliflower Crust
Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza-PastaBrick Oven, Crispy Crust, Award-Winning
Olde Towne Pizza & PastaFamily-Owned, Authentic Cuisine, Award-Winning

Williamsburg’s pizza scene is rich with options for every preference and dietary need. Whether you’re looking for the best pizza in town or exploring gluten-free and vegan options, you’ll find the perfect slice right here. And if you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Brooklyn or the best pizza in Atlanta, check out our other guides to find your next favorite pizzeria.

Standout Pizzerias

In Williamsburg, finding the best pizza is like finding the Holy Grail. Here are some pizzerias that have captured my taste buds and heart.

Sizzler Pizza

Sizzler Pizza is my go-to when I want a great pizza and an even better sub. Their homemade rolls are the stuff of legend. Seriously, I dream about those rolls. You can find more details here.

ItemRating (out of 5)

Small Town Pizza

Small Town Pizza is exactly what you’d expect: a cozy little spot with top-notch pies. It’s like they’ve bottled small-town charm and sprinkled it on their pizzas. Read more here.

ItemRating (out of 5)

Best-Way Pizza

Best-Way Pizza serves pepperoni pizza that’s so cheesy and gooey, it should come with a warning label. I’m talking about a pizza that could make you forget your own name. Check them out here.

ItemRating (out of 5)
Pepperoni Pizza4.6
Cheese Pizza4.4

Pizza Star

Pizza Star’s pizza is so good, it’s even better the next day. Who knew reheated pizza could taste so divine? It’s like they’ve cracked the code on next-day deliciousness. More details here.

ItemRating (out of 5)
Reheat Factor4.9

Original Italian Pizza

Original Italian Pizza on Rt 22 is where you go for great pizza and garlic knots that make you question your life choices (in the best way possible). The owner is friendly and remembers everyone, making it feel like home. Learn more here.

ItemRating (out of 5)
Garlic Knots4.9

If you’re ever in Williamsburg and have an insatiable craving for pizza, make sure to check out these standout pizzerias. And if you’re on a pizza pilgrimage, you might also want to sample slices in other cities like best pizza in Brooklyn or best pizza in Chicago. The quest for the best pizza in the world is never-ending!

Local Favorites

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Williamsburg, the locals know best. Here are some of the top spots that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

Sal’s By Victor

Sal’s By Victor is a beloved gem in Williamsburg. Known for their gluten-free options, Sal’s does not disappoint. From gluten-free pizza to pasta, they have something for everyone (Find Me Gluten Free). The atmosphere is cozy, the staff friendly, and the pizza… legendary. If you’re a gluten-free gourmand, Sal’s is your spot.

Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano

Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano is where tradition meets culinary excellence. Serving mouthwatering, authentic pizza from a cherished family recipe, Antonio’s offers vegetarian options and even a cauliflower crust for gluten-free guests. The warm, welcoming environment makes it a perfect place to enjoy a slice with friends or family.

Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza-Pasta

Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza-Pasta is a local favorite for a reason. Their authentic brick-oven pizzas have a light, crispy crust that will transport your taste buds straight to Italy. With a delicious array of toppings, it’s no wonder they won the 2020 Best of Coastal Virginia Reader’s Choice Award (Westgate Resorts). Trust me, one bite and you’ll understand why Anna’s is the talk of the town.

Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta

Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta is a family-owned-and-operated spot that has captured the hearts of Williamsburg residents. Known for its authentic Italian cuisine and super friendly service, Olde Towne won the 2020 TripAdvisor Traveler’s Choice Award for their outstanding pizza (Westgate Resorts). The combination of hearty flavors and a welcoming atmosphere makes it a must-visit.

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg

Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg is not your average pizza place. This hip pizza chain serves stone-baked pizzas with creative flavor combinations that will blow your mind. Their pizza crusts and sauce are made in-house with no additives or preservatives. If you’re looking for a unique pizza experience, Mellow Mushroom is the place to be.

PizzeriaSpecial FeaturesAwards/Recognition
Sal’s By VictorGluten-free options, cozy atmosphereN/A
Antonio’s Ristorante ItalianoAuthentic family recipes, vegetarian and gluten-free optionsN/A
Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza-PastaBrick-oven pizza, light crispy crust2020 Best of Coastal Virginia Reader’s Choice
Olde Towne Pizza & PastaFamily-owned, authentic Italian cuisine, friendly service2020 TripAdvisor Traveler’s Choice
Mellow Mushroom WilliamsburgStone-baked pizzas, creative flavor combinations, no additives or preservativesN/A

For more pizza adventures, check out our guides on the best pizza in Brooklyn, best pizza in Boston, or even the best pizza in the world. Happy eating!

NYC-Inspired Slices

If you’re a pizza lover like me, then you know that NYC-inspired slices are the holy grail. Williamsburg offers some of the best spots to indulge in these mouthwatering delights. Here are my top picks!

Mo’s General & Fini

Mo’s General at 620 Lorimer St. is the place to be if you’re craving puffy squares or thin bar pies loaded with pepperoni and banana peppers. It’s like a pizza party in your mouth (Grub Street).

Fini, located at 305 Bedford Ave., serves up a luxurious version of the New York slice. Their rich white pie is a slice of heaven that will make you question all your life choices up to this point (Grub Street).

Mo’s GeneralPuffy squares, thin bar pies with pepperoni and banana peppers620 Lorimer St.
FiniLuxurious New York slice, rich white pie305 Bedford Ave.

L’industrie & Leo

L’industrie at 254 S. 2nd St. is famous for its burrata slice. It’s not your typical soggy-wet burrata; it’s perfection on a crust.

Leo, at 123 Havemeyer St., offers thin, crispy squares with potato toppings. Who knew potatoes on a pizza could be so life-changing? (Grub Street)

For more places to binge on pizza, check out best pizza in brooklyn.

L’industrieBurrata slice254 S. 2nd St.
LeoThin, crispy squares with potato toppings123 Havemeyer St.

Emmy Squared & Joe’s

Emmy Squared at 364 Grand St. specializes in Detroit-style pizza. Think thick, cheesy, and crispy edges. It’s like a pizza hug for your taste buds.

Joe’s at 216 Bedford Ave. is your go-to for traditional New York slices. It’s the classic, no-nonsense pizza that makes you feel like a true New Yorker.

Emmy SquaredDetroit-style pizza364 Grand St.
Joe’sTraditional New York slices216 Bedford Ave.

Best Pizza & Williamsburg Pizza

Best Pizza at 33 Havemeyer St. is a forerunner in NYC’s slice-shop renaissance. They’re like the OG of amazing slices, setting the standard for what a pizza should be.

Williamsburg Pizza at 265 Union Ave. offers a variety of grandma slices. The owner migrated from Gravesend, bringing with him the secrets of Real Pizza magic.

For the ultimate pizza tour, don’t forget to explore best pizza in manhattan.

Best PizzaNYC slice-shop renaissance33 Havemeyer St.
Williamsburg PizzaVariety of grandma slices265 Union Ave.

So, if you’re hunting for the best pizza in Williamsburg, these spots are your go-to destinations. Happy munching!

Vegan & Gluten-Free Options

When it comes to satisfying your pizza cravings while sticking to vegan or gluten-free diets, Williamsburg has some stellar options. Here are my top picks for the best vegan and gluten-free pizzas in the area.

Vinnie’s Pizzeria

If you’re looking for vegan pizza options, Vinnie’s Pizzeria should be your first stop. Located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, Vinnie’s offers a variety of delicious vegan pizzas that have been raved about by customers. With a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to quality, Vinnie’s ensures that you don’t have to sacrifice taste for dietary restrictions.

Best Pizza in Williamsburg

Best Pizza in Williamsburg lives up to its name by providing a range of options, including sandwiches and gluten-free pizzas. The gluten-free crust is a crowd-pleaser, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. It’s a great place to enjoy a slice without worrying about gluten.

L’industrie Pizzeria

L’industrie Pizzeria is another gem in Williamsburg that offers vegan pizza options. Their pizzas are free from meat and cheese but packed with flavor. The ambiance is cozy, making it a perfect spot for a casual night out with friends or family. Check out their vegan selections for a delightful experience.

Leuca & 7 Grain Army

Leuca offers vegan pizza options that are sure to impress. Although the menu details are limited, customers have praised the vegan selections for their taste and quality.

For those in need of gluten-free options, 7 Grain Army in Williamsburg is a must-visit. Their gluten-free pizza is considered superior to other gluten-free choices in the area. With a focus on quality ingredients and exceptional taste, 7 Grain Army ensures that everyone can enjoy a delicious slice.

PizzeriaVegan OptionsGluten-Free Options
Vinnie’s PizzeriaYesNo
Best Pizza in WilliamsburgNoYes
L’industrie PizzeriaYesNo
7 Grain ArmyNoYes

For more information on the best pizza in other cities, check out best pizza in Chicago or best pizza in Brooklyn. If you’re traveling and need a pizza fix, there’s always best pizza in Houston or best pizza in Las Vegas.