Wildwood Pizza Scene

Hey there, fellow pizza lover! If you’re like me and can’t resist a good slice, then Wildwood, New Jersey, is your kind of place. This beachside town is packed with pizzerias that will make your taste buds dance. Let me take you on a tour of some of the best spots to grab a pie in Wildwood and share my top picks.

Popular Pizzerias in Wildwood

Wildwood’s pizza game is strong, and a few places stand out from the crowd. Here are some of the must-visit pizzerias:

  • Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza: Nestled at 4709 New Jersey Ave, Wildwood, NJ 08260, Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza is where you go for that perfect Neapolitan-style pizza. Cooked in a 900-degree brick oven, their pies are crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. With a 4.4-star rating, it’s a hit among locals and visitors alike.

  • Napolinos: Right on the Wildwood Boardwalk, Napolinos is your go-to for a quick, tasty slice. They offer everything from classic New York-style to unique specialty pizzas. Perfect for a casual bite while enjoying the boardwalk vibes.

  • Roberto’s Ristorante & Pizzeria: Craving some authentic Italian flavors? Roberto’s is the spot. This family-owned gem serves up pizzas and Italian dishes that taste like they came straight from Nonna’s kitchen. Quality ingredients and traditional recipes make every slice a winner.

  • Sammy’s: Located near the beach, Sammy’s is a family-friendly pizzeria with a wide range of options. From classic margherita to gourmet creations, there’s something for everyone. Plus, you can enjoy your pizza with a side of ocean breeze.

  • Flippers Pizzeria: Known for their generous toppings and bold flavors, Flippers is a great choice for both classic and adventurous pizza lovers. Their Buffalo Chicken pizza is a must-try. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or a whole pie, Flippers won’t disappoint.

Best Pizza Recommendations

After munching my way through Wildwood, here are my top picks for the ultimate pizza experience:

  • Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza: If you’re after authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, Poppi’s is a must. Their brick oven magic results in a pizza that’s crispy yet chewy. The Margherita pizza is a standout, showcasing the simple, delicious flavors of Italy.

  • Sam’s Pizza Palace: Located on the Wildwood Boardwalk, Sam’s Pizza Palace is famous for its generous toppings and flavorful sauces. Their specialty pizzas, like the White Spinach and Meat Lovers, are indulgent and satisfying.

  • Mack’s Pizza: You can’t talk about Wildwood pizza without mentioning Mack’s. Serving thin-crust pizza since 1953, Mack’s is an icon. Their unique cheese blend and crispy crust make their plain pizza a classic, but the Tomato Pie is also a must-try for something different.

Exploring Wildwood’s pizza scene has been a delicious adventure. These pizzerias and my recommendations are just the beginning. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, I encourage you to dive into your own pizza quest and uncover the hidden gems that will satisfy your cravings in Wildwood. Enjoy every slice!

Top Pizza Spots in Wildwood

Looking for the best pizza in Wildwood? We’ve got you covered with five pizzerias that locals and visitors rave about. Let’s dig in:

Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza

Craving some hand-crafted Neapolitan-style pizza? Head over to Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza at 4709 New Jersey Ave, Wildwood, NJ 08260. Their pizzas are cooked in a traditional brick oven at a sizzling 900 degrees, giving you that perfect crispy crust with a soft, chewy center. No wonder Poppi’s is famous for its authentic Neapolitan pizza.

Poppi’s scores a solid 4.4 stars on Google, with customers loving the rich flavors and quality. Just a heads-up: some folks have mentioned it gets pretty chilly inside during winter (Yelp). But hey, the pizza is worth it!


For a cozy vibe and classic Italian flavors, Napolinos is a go-to. Located at [insert address], this spot offers a variety of traditional and specialty pizzas. Whether you’re into a simple Margherita or a loaded meat lover’s pie, Napolinos has your back. They use top-notch ingredients and have truly mastered the art of pizza-making.

Roberto’s Ristorante & Pizzeria

Roberto’s Ristorante & Pizzeria is a Wildwood staple, known for its friendly service and mouthwatering Italian dishes. Their pizza menu ranges from classic New York-style pies to creative specialty options. With generous toppings and a tasty sauce, Roberto’s pizzas are a hit. Whether you dine in or take out, Roberto’s is a must-visit for pizza fans.


Sammy’s has been a local favorite for years, serving up delicious pizza in Wildwood. This family-owned spot offers New York-style and Sicilian pizzas, known for their generous toppings, flavorful sauce, and perfectly baked crust. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic cheese pizza or something more adventurous, Sammy’s has got you covered.

Flippers Pizzeria

Flippers Pizzeria is a hidden gem that deserves a shoutout for its tasty pizza creations. They focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, delivering authentic flavors in every bite. From classic cheese to specialty options like Buffalo chicken or BBQ chicken pizza, Flippers is a must-visit for pizza lovers looking for something unique.

These top pizza spots in Wildwood offer a range of flavors and styles to satisfy any pizza craving. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Margherita or an adventurous specialty pizza, these pizzerias have something for everyone. Don’t miss out on the best pizza Wildwood has to offer!

Iconic Pizza Spots in Wildwood

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Wildwood, you’re in for a treat. The town’s got some legendary spots that locals and visitors can’t stop raving about. These pizzerias have earned their stripes by serving up slices that keep folks coming back for more. Let’s check out these pizza legends:

Tony’s New York Pizza

Tony’s New York Pizza is a must-hit spot in Wildwood. They bring that classic New York-style pizza straight from Brooklyn to the Jersey Shore. This place has a loyal fan base, with Google reviewers calling it “awesome” and “absolutely the best in Wildwood” (97.3 ESPN). If you’re craving a slice of the Big Apple without leaving Wildwood, Tony’s is your go-to.

Crazy Junky

Just a stone’s throw from the Wildwood Convention Center on the Boardwalk, Crazy Junky is a newer player that’s quickly made a name for itself. Known for its top-notch ingredients and thin crust, this joint has a 4.6-star rating on Google. Locals and tourists alike are loving it (97.3 ESPN). If you’re after a slice with primo ingredients, Crazy Junky won’t disappoint.

Mack’s Pizza

Mack’s Pizza has been a Wildwood staple for over 60 years. This iconic spot is a favorite among both locals and vacationers. Mack’s is famous for its perfect cheese blend, tasty sauce, and thin crust that keeps people coming back year after year. With a 4.5-star rating, it’s clear Mack’s has stood the test of time (97.3 ESPN). When you’re in Wildwood, a stop at Mack’s is a must for any pizza lover.

Sam’s Pizza Palace

For a slice of nostalgia and a taste of history, Sam’s Pizza Palace is the place to be. This iconic pizzeria set the standard for Boardwalk Pizza nearly 70 years ago. Sam’s is known for its thicker crust and less sweet sauce, winning over the hearts of many. With a 4.4-star rating, Sam’s continues to impress with its delicious cheese and classic taste. If you’re looking for that classic Boardwalk pizza vibe, Sam’s is the spot.

These iconic pizza places in Wildwood are beloved by pizza enthusiasts. Whether you’re in the mood for a New York-style slice, a thin crust masterpiece, or a taste of Boardwalk history, these pizzerias deliver on flavor and quality. So, next time you’re in Wildwood, make sure to hit up Tony’s New York Pizza, Crazy Junky, Mack’s Pizza, and Sam’s Pizza Palace for a pizza experience you won’t forget.

Wildwood Pizza Rankings

Craving the best pizza in Wildwood? You’re in the right place! Here’s the lowdown on the top pizzerias in Wildwood for 2023, plus where to snag the best value slices in town.

Top 5 Pizzerias of 2023

Finding the best pizza in Wildwood is no easy feat. After some serious taste-testing and research, we’ve nailed down the top 5 pizzerias of 2023. These spots earned their stripes based on taste, quality, and rave reviews from customers.

1Olympic Pizza
2Steak ‘Em Up
3Mack’s Pizza
5Little Angelo’s Pizza Spot

These pizzerias are the real deal, each bringing their own unique flavors to the table. From Olympic Pizza’s killer toppings to the authentic cheesesteaks at Steak ‘Em Up, you’re in for a treat no matter where you go.

Remember, these rankings are based on personal preferences. The best pizza is the one that hits your taste buds just right and keeps you coming back for more.

Best Value Slices in Wildwood

Who says you need to empty your wallet for a tasty slice? In Wildwood, you can find plenty of spots offering great pizza without the hefty price tag. These pizzerias have been rated using the Pizza to Price to Points Ratio (P3R) formula, which considers taste, price, and size.

1Steak ‘Em Up
2Mack’s Pizza
3Olympic Flame
4Original Hot Spot

These pizzerias have nailed the balance between taste, price, and portion size, making them the go-to spots for the best value slices in Wildwood. Whether you’re after a classic cheese slice or something loaded with toppings, these places won’t let you down.

Keep in mind, pizza preferences are personal, and what you consider the “best value” might differ. But these pizzerias have earned their spots by consistently serving up delicious slices at prices that won’t break the bank.

So, get ready for a pizza adventure in Wildwood! Whether you’re hitting up the top-ranked pizzerias or hunting for the best bang for your buck, you’re in for a mouthwatering experience. Enjoy every cheesy, saucy bite!

Wildwood’s Pizza Adventures

Pizza in Wildwood isn’t just food; it’s an experience. From giant slices to unexpected twists, let’s dive into some of the most unforgettable pizza moments you can have in this lively town.

Monster Slices in Wildwood

Got a hunger that just won’t quit? Wildwood’s got your back. In 2022, Joe’s Pizzeria snagged the title for the biggest pizza slices around, measuring a jaw-dropping 13.0 x 8.0 inches—yeah, that’s 52.0 square inches of cheesy goodness! These slices aren’t just a snack; they’re a full-on meal (Wildwood Pizza Tour).

But Joe’s isn’t the only game in town. Founders Grub & Pub dishes out slices at 11.5 x 8.0 inches, while 3 Brothers and Crazy Junkie serve up 10.0 x 8.0 inch slices. Little Angelo’s and Original Hot Spot aren’t far behind with 9.5 x 8.0 inch slices. Perfect for those with a big appetite or anyone wanting to share a pizza adventure with friends and family.

The Comeback Slice

In Wildwood’s ever-changing pizza scene, there’s always room for a comeback. Pizzerias are constantly tweaking their recipes, and sometimes, the results are spectacular. In 2023, Snow White took home the “Most Improved Slice” award. With an average rating jumping from a sad 0.9 in 2022 to a respectable 2.88 in 2023, it’s proof that hard work and a little innovation can make a world of difference (Wildwood Pizza Tour).

The Slices That Spark Debate

Pizza can be a hot topic, and in Wildwood, some slices have stirred up quite the conversation. The most talked-about slices of 2023 come from Hot Spot Cafe, Original Hot Spot, Wally’s, and Founders. These slices have divided pizza lovers, with some raving about their unique flavors and others, well, not so much (Wildwood Pizza Tour). Original Hot Spot and Founders Grub & Pub, in particular, got thumbs-up from three out of four reviewers. But hey, the best way to settle the debate is to try them yourself and see where you land.

Whether you’re tackling a giant slice, witnessing a pizza’s glow-up, or diving into heated pizza debates, Wildwood’s got a pizza experience for everyone. So go ahead, step out of your comfort zone and explore the diverse pizza scene this coastal town has to offer. You might just find your new favorite slice in Wildwood.