Tulsa’s Pizza Gems

Looking for the best pizza in Tulsa? We’ve got a couple of spots that are sure to hit the mark. Let’s dive into Buddy’s Pizza Legacy and Nola’s Creole and Cocktails Delight.

Buddy’s Pizza Legacy

Buddy’s Pizza in Detroit isn’t just a pizzeria; it’s a slice of history. This place has been around since Prohibition, when Gus Guerra ran it as a speakeasy. Fast forward to the late 1940s, and Buddy’s became famous for its square pies with crispy edges and loads of sauce. These hearty squares are a Detroit staple and a must-try for any pizza lover (Food & Wine).

Nola’s Creole and Cocktails Delight

Nola’s Creole and Cocktails might not scream “pizza joint,” but trust us, their pizza is worth the visit. Known for their Voodoo Chicken, which some folks say is the best meal they’ve ever had (Yelp), Nola’s offers a unique pizza experience. The mix of flavors and top-notch ingredients make it a must-visit for pizza fans in Tulsa.

Tulsa’s pizza scene doesn’t stop there. The city is packed with pizza places, each offering something different. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or something a bit more adventurous, Tulsa has got you covered. So, grab your friends and start your pizza adventure in Tulsa.

Andolini’s Pizza Experience

If you’re hunting for the best pizza in Tulsa, look no further than Andolini’s Pizza. Since 2005, Andolini’s has been the go-to spot for locals and visitors craving a slice of heaven. Their pizzas come in sizes that would make any pizza lover’s heart skip a beat—14, 16, and a whopping 20 inches.

Andolini’s isn’t just about size; it’s about quality. They serve up a “Tulsa Style” pizza that’s raw, honest, and downright delicious. Freshly ground basil, extra virgin olive oil, and pistachios for their unique pesto are just a few of the top-notch ingredients they use. Their dough? Made from specially milled Oklahoma flour. Every bite of their hand-tossed pizzas is a burst of flavor.

Andolini’s Menu Highlights

Andolini’s menu is a playground for your taste buds. Whether you like classic flavors or adventurous toppings, they’ve got you covered. Here are some must-tries:

  • Margherita Pizza: This classic never goes out of style. Fresh mozzarella, basil, and their signature red sauce make it a simple yet mouthwatering choice.

  • Tulsa Flag Pizza: A tribute to Tulsa, this pizza is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, red onions, green olives, jalapeños, and red sauce. It’s a local favorite that packs a punch.

  • Pistachio Pesto Pizza: Feeling adventurous? This one’s for you. Pistachio pesto, mozzarella, gorgonzola cheese, prosciutto, and roasted red peppers come together for a savory, nutty delight.

Want to see more? Check out their full menu on their website.

Hideaway Pizza Tradition

Another Tulsa treasure is Hideaway Pizza. Founded in 1957 by Richard “The Big Kahuna” Dermer and his wife, Marti, Hideaway Pizza started near Oklahoma State University in Stillwater. It quickly became a beloved institution.

Hideaway Pizza sticks to what they know best—delicious, time-tested recipes. Their dough rises for at least three days, making for a light and airy crust. Their classic red sauce is slow-simmered to perfection.

With a focus on traditional flavors and quality ingredients, Hideaway Pizza offers a wide range of options. Whether you’re in the mood for a simple cheese pizza or something more daring, their menu has something for everyone.

For pizza lovers in Tulsa, Andolini’s and Hideaway Pizza are must-visits. These two spots offer unique experiences that show just how much passion goes into making the best pizzas in town. So grab your friends and family and get ready for a pizza adventure you won’t forget.

Local Pizza Favorites

Looking for the best pizza in Tulsa? Two local spots are the talk of the town. Whether you’re after a budget-friendly slice or a taste of tradition, Tulsa’s got you covered.

NYC Pizza: Wallet-Friendly Goodness

Craving pizza without emptying your pockets? NYC Pizza is your go-to. This joint brings a slice of the Big Apple to Tulsa, serving up New York-style pizza that’s both tasty and easy on the wallet.

Locals and visitors rave about NYC Pizza. Their menu is packed with classic toppings like pepperoni and margherita, all at prices that won’t make you cringe. If you want a delicious slice without the hefty price tag, NYC Pizza is the spot.

Old World Pizza: A Taste of Tradition

If you’re after something with a bit more flair, Old World Pizza is where you need to be. Known for some of the best pizza in Tulsa, their supreme pizza is a crowd favorite. Imagine a perfect blend of savory meats, fresh veggies, and gooey cheese, all baked to perfection.

Old World Pizza takes their craft seriously. They use traditional methods to create an authentic pizza experience. The crust is just right—crispy yet chewy. The sauce is tangy and bursting with flavor. And the toppings? Handpicked to ensure every bite is a flavor explosion. Each slice is a nod to the rich heritage and passion behind their pizzas.

So, whether you’re in the mood for a classic New York slice or a pizza that takes you back in time, Tulsa has something for you. Swing by NYC Pizza for affordable, delicious options, or treat yourself to the timeless quality of Old World Pizza.

Want to explore more pizza hotspots? Check out our articles on the best pizza in Oklahoma City, best pizza in Virginia Beach, best pizza in Queens, best pizza in Sarasota, best pizza in Memphis, and many more.

Unique Pizza Offerings

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Tulsa, two places you can’t miss are Savastano’s Pizzeria and The Wedge Pizzeria. These spots serve up some seriously tasty and unique pies.

Savastano’s Deep Dish Delight

Savastano’s Pizzeria is famous for its Chicago-style deep dish pizza. Picture this: a pizza that’s two inches thick, 14 inches wide, and weighs a hefty eight pounds! It’s loaded with all the good stuff like pepperoni, Italian sausage, and sautéed mushrooms. This is the kind of pizza that makes you forget about everything else (TravelOK).

Now, a pizza this big takes its sweet time in the oven, but trust me, it’s worth the wait. The crust comes out crispy and golden, the cheese is gooey, and the filling is rich and flavorful. It’s perfect for sharing with friends or family, or if you’re just really hungry and want to treat yourself.

The Wedge Pizzeria Wood-Fired Creations

Over in Oklahoma City, The Wedge Pizzeria is whipping up some amazing wood-fired pizzas. They use top-notch ingredients and come up with some pretty creative flavor combos. No wonder they’ve got a solid rep for great pizza.

Take the Italian Stallion, for example. It’s got port wine and sundried tomato sauce, mozzarella, roasted fennel, and Italian sausage. Or try the Napoli, with toasted walnuts, Asiago cheese, arugula, rosemary, and pancetta. These pizzas have a smoky, charred crust from the wood-fired oven that makes them both familiar and exciting (TravelOK).

The Wedge Pizzeria has a cozy vibe, making it a great spot to hang out with friends or family while enjoying their delicious pizzas. They also use fresh, locally sourced ingredients, which adds an extra touch of quality to their pies.

So whether you’re craving a classic deep dish from Savastano’s or eager to try the wood-fired wonders at The Wedge, Tulsa has got you covered. Dive into a pizza adventure and taste what makes these places stand out in Tulsa’s pizza scene.

Hidden Pizza Treasures

Looking for the best pizza in Tulsa? Let me spill the beans on a couple of hidden gems that are sure to tickle your taste buds. Two spots you absolutely can’t miss are Grateful Head Pizza Oven & Tap Room and Jo’s Famous Pizza Specialties.

Grateful Head Pizza Oven & Tap Room

Tucked away in Hochatown, Grateful Head Pizza Oven & Tap Room is a pizza lover’s paradise. This place is all about serving up quirky, mouthwatering pizzas. Their star player? The Psychedelic Supremo. Imagine a pizza loaded with hamburger, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, bell peppers, red onions, mushrooms, and black olives. It’s like a flavor explosion in every bite.

And what’s pizza without a drink? Grateful Head has you covered with a great selection of draft beers and sodas. Whether you’re a beer buff or a soda sipper, you’ll find the perfect drink to wash down that delicious pie.

Jo’s Famous Pizza Specialties

With spots in Purcell and Edmond, Jo’s Famous Pizza has been dishing out topping-loaded pizzas since 1962. This place is all about creativity and flavor. At Jo’s, you can expect pizzas that go way beyond the usual toppings.

Think hot links, chopped corned beef, jalapenos, and sun-dried tomatoes. And the sauces? Oh, the sauces! They’ve got Jo’s house-made red sauce, olive oil and garlic glaze, Louisiana hot sauce, and Ponca City’s Head Country BBQ sauce. Each slice is a new adventure for your taste buds.

When you’re craving something different, Jo’s Famous Pizza Specialties is the place to be. Their unique and tasty pies will have you coming back for more.

So, if you’re in Tulsa and on the hunt for some killer pizza, make sure to check out these hidden treasures. Whether you hit up Grateful Head Pizza Oven & Tap Room or Jo’s Famous Pizza Specialties, you’re in for a treat. Grab a slice and savor the flavors that make these spots stand out in Tulsa’s pizza scene.