Pizza Delights in Times Square

The Hunt for Classic New York Slice

Finding a classic New York slice in Times Square is like searching for a needle in a haystack filled with Neapolitan-style pizzerias. The influx of these fancy, thin-crusted invaders has made the classic New York slice more of a rarity. But fear not, dear pizza lovers, I’ve scoured the area and tasted more slices than I care to admit, all in the name of finding the best pizza in Times Square.

When you think of a classic New York slice, imagine a thin, yet sturdy crust with just the right amount of chewiness, topped with a rich tomato sauce and a generous layer of gooey mozzarella. This is the pizza that dreams are made of. And while you might have to navigate through a sea of artisanal pie shops, rest assured, the classic slice is still out there waiting for you.

Dollar Slice Joints vs. Quality Pizzerias

Ah, the age-old debate: dollar slice joints versus quality pizzerias. In Times Square, you’ll find a plethora of both, each vying for your hard-earned pizza dollars. But which is truly worth it? Let me break it down for you.

Dollar Slice Joints

Dollar slice joints are the fast food equivalent of the pizza world. They’re cheap, they’re quick, and they’re everywhere. You can grab a slice for as low as $1, which is perfect when you’re on the go or just need a quick fix. However, the quality often leaves much to be desired. These slices can be greasy, with questionable sauce and cheese that might make you question your life choices.

Dollar Slice JointPrice per SliceQuality Rating
2 Bros Pizza$1⭐⭐
99 Cent Fresh Pizza$1⭐⭐
NY Fresh Pizza$1.25

Most of these joints have displaced far superior pizzerias, leading to a decline in the availability of quality pizzas as people often opt for cheaper, lower-quality slices.

Quality Pizzerias

On the other hand, quality pizzerias are where the magic happens. These places use better ingredients, skilled craftsmanship, and often have a rich history behind their recipes. The slices are pricier, but oh so worth it. The crust is perfectly baked, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese… let’s just say it’s a cheese lover’s paradise.

Quality PizzeriaPrice per SliceQuality Rating
Joe’s Pizza$3.50⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
John’s of Times Square$4⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Famous Original Ray’s Pizza$3⭐⭐⭐⭐

For those who truly appreciate pizza, these quality pizzerias are a must-visit. The enjoyment of pizza is paramount, and these spots make sure every bite is an experience to savor and appreciate.

Whether you prefer the quick and dirty thrill of a dollar slice or the culinary delight of a quality pizzeria, Times Square has something for every pizza lover. So go ahead, indulge in the best pizza in Times Square, and don’t forget to check out the best pizza in Brooklyn and the best pizza in Manhattan for more delicious options.

Top Picks for Pizza in Times Square

As a pizza enthusiast, I’ve scoured the bustling streets of Times Square to bring you my top picks for the best pizza in the area. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic New York slice or something a bit more unique, these pizzerias have you covered.

Emmy Squared: A Unique Pizza Experience

Emmy Squared offers a delightful twist on traditional pizza by combining a New York-style grandma pie with a Detroit-style pizza. Imagine fluffy focaccia-like dough with a crispy cheese frico crust. Their menu features inventive creations like the Hawaiian pizza and the Farmhouse Pizza topped with prosciutto and asparagus. It’s a must-visit for those looking to deviate from the norm.

Pizza TypeDescription
HawaiianClassic ham and pineapple
Farmhouse PizzaProsciutto and asparagus on a crispy crust

Famous Original Ray’s Pizza: Tradition & Taste

Famous Original Ray’s Pizza is a Times Square staple, serving up traditional New York-style pizza. They cater to late-night cravings, staying open until 1am on weeknights and 3am on weekends. Their Famous Special Pizza Pie, loaded with various toppings, is a crowd favorite (Travel Mag). If you’re a night owl, this is your go-to spot.

Close Time1am3am

Joe’s Pizza: A Movie-Worthy Slice

Joe’s Pizza gained fame after being featured in the 2004 Spider-Man 2 movie, and it lives up to the hype with its quintessential New York-style slices. They offer seven types of pizza, available by the slice or as an 8-slice pie ranging from $23 to $31. It’s a slice that even Peter Parker would approve of.

Pizza TypePrice Range ($)
8-Slice Pie23 – 31

John’s of Times Square: Coal-Fired Goodness

John’s of Times Square uses coal-fired brick ovens, ensuring that no two pizzas are ever the same. Their menu includes a variety of thin-crust options like traditional, margherita, pizza bianca, and shrimp fra diavolo. The coal-fired method imparts a unique flavor that sets their pies apart.

Pizza TypeDescription
TraditionalClassic thin crust
MargheritaFresh tomatoes and basil
Pizza BiancaWhite pizza with ricotta
Shrimp Fra DiavoloSpicy shrimp and tomato sauce

Carnegie Pizza: Variety and Authenticity

Carnegie Pizza offers a wide range of New York pizza styles, from classic New York pies to grandma-style squares and Sicilian-style slices. They also cater to dietary needs with gluten-free options and serve up delicious appetizers like garlic knots. Variety and authenticity are the hallmarks of this pizzeria.

Pizza TypeDescription
Classic New York PiesTraditional large slices
Grandma-Style SquaresThick, square slices with a crispy bottom
Sicilian-StyleThick, airy crust with robust toppings
Gluten-Free OptionsVarious pizzas available gluten-free
AppetizersGarlic knots and more

For more top pizza picks, check out our recommendations for the best pizza in manhattan and other cities. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these pizzerias in Times Square are sure to satisfy your pizza cravings.

Customer Favorites in Times Square

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Times Square, these customer favorites are sure to satisfy your cravings. From hidden gems to popular spots, here’s a list of the top places to grab a slice in the bustling heart of New York City.

Patzeria Perfect Pizza: A Gem in the Crowds

Patzeria Perfect Pizza is often hailed as the best pizza in Times Square according to customer reviews. This cozy spot is known for its friendly staff and intimate atmosphere. The pizza here is a perfect blend of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel right at home in the middle of the city’s chaos.

AtmosphereSmall and cozy
ServiceFriendly staff
PopularityHigh customer ratings

Carnegie Pizza: Speedy and Delicious

Carnegie Pizza is a favorite among locals and tourists alike, especially for its quick service and delicious slices. Their vodka pizza and BBQ flavors are particularly popular (Yelp). This spot is perfect for those who need a fast yet satisfying meal in the heart of Times Square.

SpeedQuick service
SpecialtyVodka and BBQ pizza
PopularityHigh customer ratings

Little Italy Pizza: Slice of Tradition

Little Italy Pizza brings a taste of traditional New York pizza to Times Square. Known for its crispy crust and fast service, this place is a go-to for a quick and tasty slice (Yelp). If you’re craving a classic New York slice, this is the spot to visit.

SpecialtyTraditional New York pizza

Famous Original Ray’s Pizza: Late-Night Bite

Famous Original Ray’s Pizza is a staple for a quick slice, especially late on Friday nights. Whether you’re finishing a night out or just need a quick bite, Ray’s is a reliable choice for a delicious slice.

SpecialtyQuick slices
TimingLate-night availability
PopularityHigh customer ratings

Paul’s On Times Square: Margherita Marvel

Paul’s On Times Square is renowned for its outstanding margherita pizza and delicious Caesar salad (Yelp). This spot offers a more refined pizza experience, making it a notable choice for pizza lovers in the area.

SpecialtyMargherita pizza
Additional OfferingsCaesar salad
PopularityHigh customer ratings

Craving more pizza adventures? Check out our recommendations for the best pizza in Brooklyn, best pizza in Chicago, and the best pizza in the world. Happy eating!