Best Pizza Spots in Tampa

If you’re a pizza fanatic like me, Tampa’s got some hidden gems that’ll make your taste buds dance. Here are my top picks for the best pizza in Tampa.

Santoro’s Pizzeria

Santoro’s Pizzeria is a cozy little spot where the staff treats you like family. The pizza here is legendary—think crispy crust, gooey cheese, and toppings that’ll make you sing. According to Yelp, the pizza is top-notch, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. If you’re craving a classic pizzeria experience, this is your place.

GINO’s Restaurant & Bar

Let’s talk about GINO’s Restaurant & Bar. If you haven’t tried their Margarita Pizza, you’re missing out. One Yelp reviewer even called it the best they’ve ever had. GINO’s mixes a traditional Italian vibe with a modern twist, making it a delightful spot to enjoy a slice or two.

Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza

Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza brings a taste of New York right to Tampa. The quality here is amazing, with that authentic NY-style crust that’s thin yet chewy. According to Yelp, this place is a must-visit for pizza aficionados. The slices are big enough to fold in half, just like in the Big Apple.

Tampa Pizza Company

Tampa Pizza Company is one of my personal favorites. They don’t just serve amazing pizza; they also have fantastic wings and a Nutella pizza dessert that will blow your mind. A satisfied customer on Yelp raved about the variety and quality of the food here. It’s a great spot for a family outing or a casual dinner with friends.

Hot Rocks Pizza

Hot Rocks Pizza is known for its great selection and good prices. They cater to various preferences, making it a versatile spot for pizza lovers. According to a customer review on Yelp, the choices here are fantastic, and the quality is consistently high. Whether you like your pizza traditional or with a twist, Hot Rocks has got you covered.

Here’s a quick comparison table to help you decide where to get your next pizza fix:

Pizza SpotSpecialtyRating
Santoro’s PizzeriaClassic Pizzeria Experience⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
GINO’s Restaurant & BarMargarita Pizza⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Eddie & Sam’s NY PizzaNY-Style Pizza⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Tampa Pizza CompanyVariety and Desserts⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Hot Rocks PizzaSelection and Prices⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

For more pizza adventures, check out my other guides on the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and best pizza in Miami. Let’s keep this pizza party going!

Unique Pizza Offerings

Alright, pizza lovers, I’ve been on a mission to find the best pizza in Tampa. From classic slices to creative concoctions, here are some standout unique pizza offerings you absolutely must try.

Santoro’s Pizza Specialties

Santoro’s Pizza is an absolute must-visit in Tampa. This place offers an authentic “Jersey slice” that will make you rethink your life choices. They also serve a variety of specialty pies like Philly cheesesteak, buffalo chicken, and meatball marinara. If you’re feeling extra hungry, their daily lunch special includes a plain slice, a specialty slice, and a fountain drink for just $7 (Sunkissed in Tampa).

Specialty PizzaDescription
Philly CheesesteakLoaded with steak, onions, and peppers
Buffalo ChickenSpicy buffalo chicken with blue cheese
Meatball MarinaraClassic meatballs smothered in marinara sauce

Westshore Pizza’s Pizza Squares

Westshore Pizza, known as “Tampa’s original pizza chain,” has locations scattered across Tampa Bay. What makes them unique is their option to have pizzas cut into squares, which is ideal for sharing. Besides pizza, they also offer wings, burgers, and calzones (Sunkissed in Tampa).

Pizza TypeDescription
Square Cut PizzaPerfect for sharing at parties
WingsChoose from a variety of sauces
Burgers & CalzonesGreat for non-pizza lovers

Flippers Pizzeria’s Arugula & Prosciutto Pizza

Flippers Pizzeria in Tampa offers delicious pies complemented by irresistible breadsticks. Their Arugula & Prosciutto pizza is a standout favorite, featuring fresh arugula, savory prosciutto, and perfectly melted cheese. They also have a location in St. Pete.

Specialty PizzaDescription
Arugula & ProsciuttoFresh arugula, savory prosciutto, melted cheese

Tampa Bay Brewing Company’s Pizza Cubano

Tampa Bay Brewing Company in Ybor City not only serves great beer but also offers delicious pizza options. Their menu includes a creative Pizza Cubano, blending the flavors of a Cuban sandwich with a classic pizza. The brewery features 24 rotating taps and has live music on weekends.

Specialty PizzaDescription
Pizza CubanoCuban sandwich flavors on a pizza

Bavaro’s Neapolitan Experience

Bavaro’s Pizza is a must-visit pizza place in Tampa, offering an authentic Neapolitan pizza experience. They have multiple locations throughout Tampa Bay and pride themselves on crafting Neapolitan pizzas with hand-stretched dough using a 100-year-old yeast culture. You can even add imported bufala mozzarella for extra flavor.

Specialty PizzaDescription
Neapolitan PizzaHand-stretched dough, 100-year-old yeast culture
Bufala MozzarellaImported for extra flavor

For more delicious options, check out my reviews on the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and best pizza in Boston.

Top-Rated Pizza Places

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Tampa, there are a few spots that stand out above the rest. Here are my top picks for pizza joints that will have you coming back for more.

Pitza Pizza

First on the list is Pitza Pizza, holding the highest ranking among pizza restaurants in Tampa with a stellar rating of 4.7/5 based on 82 reviews. Their crust is pure perfection, crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The toppings are always fresh, and they don’t skimp on the cheese. If you’re looking for pizza bliss, Pitza Pizza is the place to be.

MetricRating
Overall Rating4.7/5
Number of Reviews82
SpecialtyClassic Margherita

Tampa Taco

Next up is Tampa Taco, which might sound like a taco joint, but trust me, their pizza game is strong. Ranked the second-best pizza restaurant in Tampa with a rating of 4.6/5 from 32 reviews (WFLA), Tampa Taco offers some unique pizza options that will tantalize your taste buds. Their fusion pizzas, like the Taco Pizza, are a must-try.

MetricRating
Overall Rating4.6/5
Number of Reviews32
SpecialtyTaco Pizza

Fabrica Pizza

Fabrica Pizza is not just a pizza place; it’s an experience. Ranked as the fifth-best pizza restaurant in Tampa, with a rating of 4.5/5 based on a whopping 472 reviews (WFLA), Fabrica Pizza offers top-notch customization options for those who like their pizza just so. You can choose from a variety of fresh ingredients to create your dream pizza.

MetricRating
Overall Rating4.5/5
Number of Reviews472
SpecialtyCustomizable Pizzas

For more on their customization options, check out our Fabrica Pizza’s Customization Options article.

The Grill At Morris Bridge

The Grill At Morris Bridge might sound like a place for burgers, but don’t let the name fool you. Holding the fourth position among pizza restaurants in Tampa with a rating of 4.5/5 from 120 reviews (WFLA), their pizza is a hidden gem. The Grill offers a cozy atmosphere and a menu that will make your mouth water.

MetricRating
Overall Rating4.5/5
Number of Reviews120
SpecialtyBBQ Chicken Pizza

Magdalena’s Pizzeria

Last but certainly not least is Magdalena’s Pizzeria. Securing the third spot among pizza restaurants in Tampa, this place boasts a rating of 4.5/5 based on 225 reviews (WFLA). Their pizza is authentic and delicious, and they offer a variety of specialty pies that will make you fall in love at first bite.

MetricRating
Overall Rating4.5/5
Number of Reviews225
SpecialtyFour Cheese Pizza

For more pizza recommendations, check out our guides on the best pizza in Chicago and the best pizza in Brooklyn. If you’re ever in these cities, you’ll know where to go for a slice of heaven.

Insider Reviews and Ratings

Dave Portnoy’s Pizza Tour

Dave Portnoy, the pizza aficionado from Barstool Sports, has made his way through Tampa on his “One Bite Pizza” tour. He visited several spots, including Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza, which he rated a solid 7.1 five years ago. But the highest praise went to Nona Slice House in Safety Harbor with an impressive 8.1 rating. For those looking to follow in Portnoy’s footsteps, these spots are a must-visit for the best pizza in Tampa.

Top-Rated Pizza Restaurants in Tampa

When it comes to ratings, Pitza Pizza takes the crown with a stellar 4.7/5 based on 82 reviews (WFLA). Tampa Taco follows closely with a 4.6/5 from 32 reviews. These ratings are based on customer satisfaction and the overall dining experience, making them top contenders for the best pizza in Tampa.

RestaurantRatingNumber of Reviews
Pitza Pizza4.7/582
Tampa Taco4.6/532

50TopPizza.It Recognition

Fabrica Pizza in Tampa has earned international acclaim, being ranked #15 in the country by 50TopPizza.It (Q105). This recognition comes from a prestigious team of food and beverage journalists from Italy. Fabrica’s dedication to honoring heritage and respecting ingredients shines through in their Neapolitan pizza offerings. Their personalized 12-inch pizzas and the option to order frozen pies online have made them a favorite among pizza lovers.

Yelp’s Top 100 Pizza Spots List

According to a study by Stacker, Eddie & Sam’s in downtown Tampa has been named the best pizza spot in Tampa based on Yelp’s top 100 pizza spots list (My Q105). The study considered factors such as total volume and ratings of reviews, solidifying Eddie & Sam’s reputation as a go-to for pizza enthusiasts.

Customer Reviews and Recommendations

Customer reviews are often the best indicator of a great pizza spot. Here are some highlights from Tampa’s top-rated pizzerias:

  • Pitza Pizza: Known for its crispy crust and generous toppings, reviewers rave about the authentic taste and friendly service.
  • Tampa Taco: While it may sound like a taco joint, their pizza is highly praised for its unique flavors and fresh ingredients.
  • Fabrica Pizza: Customers love the customization options and the quality of the Neapolitan-style pies. Their frozen pizza options have also been a hit during the pandemic.

For more insights into top-rated pizza places across the country, check out our articles on the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and more. Whether you’re in Tampa or exploring other cities, there’s always a slice of pizza paradise waiting for you!

Specialty Pizzas and Menu Options

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Tampa, you’ve come to the right place. Let’s dive into the delicious offerings at T.J.’s and Fabrica Pizza, two of Tampa’s finest pizza joints.

T.J.’s Signature Pizzas

T.J.’s in Indian Rocks Beach is known for its high-quality ingredients and delectable pizza options. Their signature pizzas feature great marinara, high-quality mozzarella, and a variety of toppings, all on a delicious brick-fired crust (CL Tampa).

Pizza SizeRegular PizzaWhite Pizza
12″$7.95$8.50
14″$8.95$9.95
16″$9.95$10.95

Extra toppings cost an additional $1.00 for small pizzas and $1.75 for medium and large pizzas.

T.J.’s Gourmet Pizza Selection

For those looking to elevate their pizza experience, T.J.’s offers gourmet options that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Some of the standout choices include:

  • Spinach/Mushroom Pie: Homemade ranch dressing, three cheeses, spinach, and mushrooms.

  • 12″: $11.95

  • 14″: $14.95

  • 16″: $16.95

  • White Shrimp-Asparagus Pie: Olive oil, fresh garlic, shrimp, and asparagus.

  • 12″: $15.95

  • 14″: $17.95

T.J.’s Additional Menu Offerings

T.J.’s isn’t just about pizza. They also offer a variety of other dishes to satisfy your culinary cravings. From enormous salads to mouth-watering appetizers and hearty entrees, there’s something for everyone.

ItemPrice
Spinach Salad$5.95
Gamberoni Basilico (Shrimp Appetizer)$8.95
Seafood Medley (Entree)$23.95

For a complete dining experience, don’t miss out on their gamberoni basilico with peppercorn-seared shrimp and basil aioli or the seafood medley featuring a cold-water lobster tail, scallops, shrimp, spinach, hearts of palm, and artichoke in a garlic cream sauce over bow-tie pasta (CL Tampa).

T.J.’s House of Sweets

No meal is complete without dessert, and T.J.’s House of Sweets has got you covered. This adjacent ice-cream parlor offers a variety of flavors from mocha to Moose Tracks, along with indulgent treats like hot fudge sundaes.

Fabrica Pizza’s Customization Options

Fabrica Pizza in Tampa is all about customization. You can select up to 10 pies to create your perfect pizza box. They also offer fresh salads, appetizers, and a full drink menu, ensuring a well-rounded dining experience. Known for honoring heritage and using high-quality ingredients, Fabrica’s Neapolitan pizza offerings are a must-try for any pizza lover (Q105).

For more pizza adventures, check out our guides to the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and best pizza in Boston. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Tampa’s pizza scene has something to satisfy every craving.

Expansion and Community Engagement

Fabrica Pizza’s Second Location

I recently had the pleasure of discovering that Fabrica Pizza, one of Tampa’s finest pizzerias, has expanded to a second location on S. 7th St in St. Petersburg. This new spot showcases the success and popularity of their delectable Neapolitan pizza offerings. If you haven’t tried their pizzas yet, you might want to hop on over to either location and taste why they’ve become a local favorite. Check out our list of the best pizza in Tampa for more details.

Skatepark of Tampa (SPoT)

For all the skateboarding enthusiasts out there, the Skatepark of Tampa, aka SPoT, is a must-visit. Located at 4215 E. Columbus Dr., this iconic skatepark offers both indoor and outdoor facilities, skate products, camps, birthday parties, and even a “Girls Meetup” session (Q105). It’s the perfect place to work up an appetite before heading over to Fabrica Pizza for some post-skate deliciousness.

Kona Skatepark in Jacksonville

If you ever find yourself in Jacksonville, don’t miss the chance to visit Kona Skatepark, the oldest running public