Staten Island Pizza Scene

Discovering Pizza Treasures

Ah, Staten Island, the often-overlooked borough—unless you’re talking about pizza. As a self-proclaimed pizza lover, I took on the delicious task of finding the best pizza in Staten Island. Trust me, it was a tough job, but someone had to do it.

Staten Island is a hidden gem for gourmet pizza. From upscale pies at Dough by Licastri to the classic thin-crust delights at Joe & Pat’s, the island offers a variety of mouthwatering options. For those who love their pizza with unique ingredients, Campania and Pizzeria Giove serve up indulgent and creative pies that will make your taste buds dance.

Unique Pizza Offerings

One of the things I love about Staten Island’s pizza scene is its diversity. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita or something a bit more adventurous like a clam pie, this borough has got you covered. The key to a great clam pie, by the way, is simplicity—no overpowering the clams with too many toppings.

Let’s talk about some standout pies:

  • Mona Lisa Pizzeria: Their Gold Medal pizza is a culinary masterpiece, topped with mushroom cognac cream sauce and truffle oil. If you’re indecisive, try their half-white (mozzarella and ricotta) and half-regular pie. And don’t forget to end your meal with their Cannoli in a Cup.

  • Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern: Famous for its thin-crust pizza, Denino’s serves up a mean Margherita and the M.O.R. (meatball, onion, and ricotta) pizza. Afterward, head across the street to Ralph’s for some Italian ice.

  • Reggiano’s Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe: Known for their charred, cracker-thin crusts, Reggiano’s offers pies like the arugula-sausage, topped with fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, Italian sausage, arugula, and olive oil.

  • Joe & Pat’s: Since 1960, Joe & Pat’s has been serving wafer-thin pizza. Their Royal pie, adorned with sweet and spicy sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, mushrooms, and optional anchovies, is a must-try. The sausage curls into crispy little bowls of delicious grease—what’s not to love?

  • DOUGH by Licastri: Specializing in thin-crust pizzas, DOUGH offers unique pies like the Purple Rain, topped with bechamel, smoked mozzarella, wild mushrooms, scallions, and Peruvian peppers. The Badda Bing, with dried bing cherries, bacon, bechamel, pecorino, gorgonzola, fresh mozzarella, and orange blossom honey, is another standout.

If you’re on a pizza quest like mine, don’t forget to check out the best pizza in Brooklyn or even the best pizza in Manhattan for more cheesy adventures.

Top Pizza Spots in Staten Island

In my quest for the best pizza in Staten Island, I stumbled upon some incredible spots that left my taste buds dancing. Here are my top picks:

Denino’s Delights

Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern is a Staten Island staple that should be on every pizza lover’s radar. Their menu is a delightful mix of traditional and unique flavors. The “Mor Pie” and “Vodka Pizza” are absolute must-tries. The “Mor Pie” is loaded with savory sausage, meatballs, and pepperoni, while the “Vodka Pizza” combines creamy vodka sauce with mozzarella for a heavenly bite.

Pizza TypeDescriptionPrice ($)
Mor PieSausage, meatballs, pepperoni18.99
Vodka PizzaVodka sauce, mozzarella17.99

Don’t forget to indulge in their fried calamari and finish off with a cannoli. It’s a full-circle culinary experience that never disappoints.

Lee’s Tavern Experience

Lee’s Tavern is the kind of place where you walk in for a slice and leave with a satisfied belly and a smile. Known for their thin, crispy crust, this joint offers unique toppings like white clam and seasonal corned beef and cabbage. The combination of flavors is both intriguing and delicious.

Pizza TypeDescriptionPrice ($)
White ClamClams, garlic, mozzarella16.50
Corned Beef & CabbageCorned beef, cabbage, mozzarella18.00

The prices are reasonable, and the staff? Friendly and efficient, making it a must-visit spot for any pizza aficionado.

Mona Lisa’s Flavorful Pies

Mona Lisa Pizzeria is a cozy haven for pizza lovers. Their “Art Lover” pizza, adorned with artichokes and a blend of cheeses, is a personal favorite. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is attentive, ensuring you have a pleasant dining experience.

Pizza TypeDescriptionPrice ($)
Art LoverArtichokes, mozzarella, Parmesan19.00

The prices are pretty reasonable, and the flavors? Simply unforgettable.

Paesano’s Culinary Journey

Paesano’s Pizzeria offers more than just pizza; it’s a culinary journey. Their chicken parmigiana is mouth-watering, but the real star is their Vodka Pasta Pizza. Yes, you read that right—pizza with a vodka pasta twist. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, paired with excellent customer service, makes Paesano’s a standout.

Pizza TypeDescriptionPrice ($)
Vodka Pasta PizzaVodka sauce, pasta, mozzarella20.00

Enjoy the flavorful dishes and let the friendly staff guide you through a memorable dining experience.

For more pizza adventures, check out our guides on the best pizza in Brooklyn and the best pizza in Manhattan. If you’re traveling, you might want to explore the best pizza in Chicago or even the best pizza in the world. Happy pizza hunting!

Best Pizza Recommendations

After indulging in countless slices and exploring the pizza scene of Staten Island, I’ve compiled a list of top-notch pizzerias that left me in pizza paradise. Here are my favorites:

Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern

Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern is a Staten Island institution. Their pies are legendary and have a crispy, thin crust that provides the perfect base for the rich, flavorful toppings. One enthusiastic reviewer even claimed that Denino’s pizzas rival the best pies from Rhode Island’s Caserta’s.

CrustThin and crispy
SpecialtyClam pie
AtmosphereCasual, family-friendly

For more legendary pizza spots, check out the best pizza in the world.

Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria

Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria stands out with their Neapolitan-style pies. Their pizza boasts a perfect balance between the fluffy, tender dough and the slightly charred crust. Many consider Joe & Pat’s to serve the best pizza in Staten Island, especially if you crave that authentic Neapolitan experience.

CrustNeapolitan, slightly charred
AtmosphereCozy, rustic

For more Neapolitan gems, explore the best pizza in Naples.

Mamma Mia Pizzeria & Cucina

Mamma Mia Pizzeria & Cucina offers a delightful combination of delicious pizza and friendly service. It’s quickly become one of my favorite spots on the island. The pizzas are consistently tasty, with a perfect blend of cheese and sauce, making each bite a joyous experience (Yelp).

CrustClassic, well-balanced
AtmosphereWelcoming, family-oriented

For more family favorites, check out the best pizza in family-friendly cities.

Pizzaioli’s Crispy Slices

Pizzaioli is known for its fabulous Sicilian and regular slices. If you’re a fan of crispy, mouth-watering pizza, this is the place for you. The pies are always cooked to perfection, making it a beloved neighborhood spot.

CrustSicilian, crispy
SpecialtySicilian slice
AtmosphereLaid-back, neighborhood vibe

For more local favorites, explore the best pizza in Brooklyn.

Nonna’s Pizza Perfection

Nonna’s Pizzeria is a hidden gem. Their clam pizza is a must-try, and even their plain pies look and taste spectacular. This place is highly rated and for good reason; every slice is a testament to pizza perfection.

CrustThin, chewy
SpecialtyClam pizza
AtmosphereQuaint, charming

For more charming spots, check out the best pizza in charming cities.

For those who love exploring pizza across different cities, feel free to check out my recommendations for the best pizza in Chicago and the best pizza in Atlanta.