Sarasota’s Pizza Paradise

Got a pizza craving in Sarasota? You’re in luck! This town’s got some killer spots to grab a slice. Let’s check out the top pizza joints and the wild toppings they offer.

Top Pizza Spots in Sarasota

  1. Capo Pazzo: This New York-style pizzeria is a local legend. Fresh tomatoes and gooey mozzarella make every bite a winner. Whether you’re into classic or white pizza, Capo Pazzo’s got you covered (Yelp).

  2. Patellini’s Pizza: Known for its tasty pies at wallet-friendly prices, Patellini’s has a loyal fanbase. From classic pepperoni to funky combos, there’s something for everyone (Yelp).

  3. Sal’s Pizzeria & Pasta House: A local favorite, Sal’s serves up pizza that keeps folks coming back. Their Paisan salad is also a hit, showing they care about quality and variety (Yelp).

  4. Solorzano’s Pizza: On Webber Street, Solorzano’s is a must-visit. Known for their mouthwatering pies, it’s no wonder they’re a go-to for pizza lovers in Sarasota (Yelp).

Funky Pizza Toppings

Sarasota’s pizza joints don’t just stick to the basics. They offer some pretty unique toppings that take your pizza game to the next level:

  • Arugula: This peppery green adds a fresh kick. Perfect with prosciutto or shaved Parmesan.

  • Fig Jam: Sweet meets savory with fig jam. Pair it with goat cheese or caramelized onions for a flavor explosion.

  • Truffle Oil: A drizzle of truffle oil brings an earthy, luxurious touch. Great with mushrooms and cheeses like fontina or Gouda.

  • Balsamic Glaze: Tangy balsamic glaze adds a burst of flavor. Try it with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, or even strawberries for a sweet twist.

  • Honey: A bit of honey on your pizza balances sweet and savory. It’s amazing with salty toppings like prosciutto or blue cheese.

These toppings let you mix and match flavors, making your pizza experience anything but boring. Next time you’re in Sarasota, step out of your comfort zone and try something new.

With so many pizza places and unique toppings, Sarasota’s pizza scene is a slice of heaven. Whether you’re a fan of the classics or love experimenting with flavors, there’s something here for everyone.

Popular Pizza Places in Sarasota

Sarasota’s got some killer pizza spots that locals and visitors can’t get enough of. Two places that really stand out are Capo Pazzo and Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery & Pizzeria. Let’s dig into what makes these joints so special.

Capo Pazzo: A New York-style Gem

Capo Pazzo is a local favorite, serving up authentic New York-style pizza that’s got folks raving. Even a gas station clerk vouched for it as one of the best in town (Yelp).

What makes Capo Pazzo a hit? It’s all about the quality ingredients and old-school pizza-making. The crust is crispy yet chewy, the sauce is packed with flavor, and the toppings are generous. Whether you’re a cheese purist or a pepperoni fanatic, Capo Pazzo’s got you covered.

Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery & Pizzeria

If you’re craving that hearty Chicago-style pizza, Joey D’s in nearby Bradenton is your go-to. They’ve been bringing a taste of the Windy City to Florida for years, and people can’t get enough of it.

Joey D’s deep-dish pizza is the stuff of legends. Imagine a thick, buttery crust loaded with gooey cheese, rich sauce, and all the toppings you can handle. Each slice is a flavor bomb that’ll keep you coming back for more.

Both Capo Pazzo and Joey D’s have earned their spots in Sarasota’s pizza scene. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic New York slice or a hearty Chicago deep-dish, these places deliver the goods.

But hey, Sarasota’s just the start. There’s a whole world of pizza out there. Stick with us as we dive into nationwide pizza trends, celebrate the best pies, and uncover hidden gems across the U.S.

Nationwide Pizza Topping Trends

Pizza lovers, gather ’round! We’re diving into the toppings that make our favorite pies so irresistible. From the great pineapple debate to the classic go-to’s, let’s see what’s sizzling across the nation.

Pineapple on Pizza: Love It or Hate It?

Ah, pineapple on pizza—a topic that can turn friends into frenemies. According to research by, pineapple didn’t crack Florida’s top 10 favorite toppings. Nationwide, it sits at number 12, just behind jalapenos. But in Hawaii? It’s the king of toppings (ESPN SWFL).

People are split on this one. Fans say the sweet pineapple pairs perfectly with salty ham or bacon, creating a flavor explosion. Critics argue it messes with the traditional pizza vibe. At the end of the day, it’s all about what tickles your taste buds.

Most Loved Pizza Toppings

While pineapple sparks debate, some toppings are universally adored. These classics have been winning hearts (and stomachs) for years.

Here are some of the top contenders:

ToppingWhy We Love It
PepperoniSpicy, savory, and a must-have for many.
MushroomsEarthy flavor and a satisfying texture.
SausageWhether sweet or spicy, it packs a punch.
Bell PeppersAdds a colorful crunch to every bite.
OnionsCaramelized or raw, they bring a sweet-savory mix.
OlivesBriny and tangy, perfect for balance.
Fresh BasilAromatic and fresh, it elevates the whole pie.
Mozzarella CheeseMelty, creamy, and essential.
Tomato SauceThe tangy base that ties it all together.

Mix and match these toppings to create your dream pizza. Whether you’re into a classic Margherita with fresh basil and mozzarella or a meat-lover’s feast with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, the options are endless.

Different pizza joints might taste similar because of standardized recipes, ingredient sourcing, and cooking methods (Quora). But the best pizza is the one that makes you happy.

As we continue our pizza journey, let’s give a shout-out to the best in the biz. Up next, we’ll spotlight community awards and gala events that celebrate top-notch pizza places.

Celebrating Pizza Greatness in Sarasota

In Sarasota, we take our pizza seriously. That’s why we’ve got the Community’s Choice Awards, where locals nominate and vote for their favorite pizza spots and other businesses in the area (Your Choice Awards). This program shines a spotlight on over 480 businesses across different categories, including Dining.

Community’s Choice Awards Program

The Community’s Choice Awards is all about the love for pizza and supporting local favorites. Each year, nominations open up, giving everyone a chance to shout out their top pizza places. These nominations get whittled down to a list of finalists in the Best Pizza Joints category.

Once the finalists are set, it’s voting time. The community votes for their top pizza joints, making sure the winners are truly the people’s choice. This process is a great way to see which pizza places have won over the hearts (and taste buds) of Sarasota locals. It’s a real reflection of what the community loves, making it a go-to guide for pizza fans in the area.

Gala Celebration for Pizza Winners

The winners of the Community’s Choice Awards are revealed at a swanky gala celebration—an event that’s all about excitement and recognition for the top pizza joints. This invite-only bash is attended by the finalists and their guests, making it a night to remember.

The gala kicks off with a cocktail hour, perfect for mingling and getting into the festive spirit. Then comes a mouth-watering dinner, showcasing Sarasota’s culinary talent. Entertainment throughout the evening keeps the vibe lively and fun.

The highlight of the night is the awards presentation, where the winners in each category, including Best Pizza Joints, are announced. This moment is a big deal for the winners, celebrating their hard work and dedication to serving up amazing pizza. It’s their time to shine and get the recognition they deserve within the community.

But the celebration doesn’t stop there. The winners are also featured in a special printed section of the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, serving as a handy guide for pizza lovers. Plus, the winners are published online, spreading the word far and wide (Your Choice Awards).

The Community’s Choice Awards and the gala celebration are more than just about recognizing the best pizza; they’re about bringing the community together to celebrate a shared passion. It’s an event that highlights Sarasota’s vibrant pizza scene and the dedication of local pizza joints.

Beyond Sarasota: National Pizza Gems

Sure, Sarasota’s got some killer pizza joints, but let’s hit the road and check out some of the best pizza spots across the U.S. Buckle up, folks—this is gonna be tasty.

Best Pizza Spots Across the US

First stop, Chicago. Pequod’s Pizzeria is the talk of the town, and for good reason. According to Yelp reviews, this place is the top dog. Their pan pizza with that caramelized cheese crust? Pure magic. And don’t even get me started on their sausage pizza. Pro tip: Make a reservation to skip the wait.

Next, we jet over to the West Coast. Bestia in Los Angeles is a must-visit. Folks can’t get enough of their spicy lamb sausage pizza and the classic Margherita. The portions are huge, perfect for sharing, and the ingredients are as fresh as they come.

Now, let’s talk about a legend. Lombardi’s Pizza in New York City is the OG of American pizzerias. Their thin-crust, Neapolitan-style pies cooked over coals are a slice of history. The clam pie, Margherita, and Pepperoni, Pancetta, and Onion pizza are fan favorites.

Back to Cali, Mama D’s Italian Kitchen in Newport Beach is another gem. Their pizzas, especially The Favorites and the Margherita, are crowd-pleasers. Plus, the staff’s hospitality makes you feel right at home.

Last but not least, let’s head to South Lake Tahoe. Base Camp Pizza Co. is a hit with locals and tourists alike. Their menu is packed with unique options like the Thai chicken curry pizza and smoky BBQ chicken with bacon. They also cater to gluten-free folks, and their gluten-free pizza is just as good as the regular stuff.

Yelp’s Top-Ranked Pizzerias

Craving more recommendations? Yelp’s got your back. It’s a treasure trove of reviews and ratings from pizza lovers nationwide. Whether you’re hunting for the best pizza in Oklahoma City, Virginia Beach, Queens, Memphis, Key West, or anywhere else, Yelp’s got the scoop.

So, as we venture beyond Sarasota, we find a smorgasbord of pizza gems across the U.S. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza fan or just looking for a new spot to try, these places are sure to hit the spot. Happy eating!

The Art of Pizza Making

Pizza making isn’t just about tossing dough and slapping on toppings. It’s a craft, a passion, and sometimes, a bit of a science experiment. Let’s dig into what makes pizza so darn good and why each slice can be a masterpiece.

Pizza Styles and Techniques

Pizza styles are like snowflakes—no two are exactly alike. Each region and even individual pizzerias have their own spin. Here are some fan favorites:

  • Neapolitan Pizza: Straight outta Naples, Italy, this pizza is all about that thin, soft crust. It’s simple but oh-so-good, with fresh ingredients and a quick bake in a wood-fired oven. The result? A crust that’s slightly charred and blistered, just the way it should be.

  • New York Style Pizza: Think big, foldable slices with a thin but sturdy crust. It’s the kind of pizza you can grab on the go, loaded with tomato sauce and mozzarella. Perfect for a quick lunch or a late-night snack.

  • Chicago Deep Dish Pizza: This one’s a beast. A deep, buttery crust packed with layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings. The cheese goes on first, then the toppings, and finally, the sauce. It’s like a pizza lasagna.

  • Sicilian Pizza: Thick, rectangular, and oh-so-fluffy on the inside, yet crispy on the bottom. It’s usually topped with a rich tomato sauce and whatever else your heart desires.

These are just a few styles, but each has its own loyal fans and unique flavors. The magic happens in the dough prep, the baking, and the love that goes into each pie.

Secret to Delicious Pizza

So, what’s the secret sauce (pun intended) to making a killer pizza? Here are some tips from the pros:

  • Quality Ingredients: You can’t make a great pizza with lousy ingredients. Fresh tomatoes, premium cheeses, and locally sourced toppings make all the difference.

  • Proper Dough Preparation: The dough is the backbone of your pizza. It needs time to ferment and proof to get that perfect flavor and texture. Stretch it or roll it evenly for a consistent bake.

  • Hot Oven or Pizza Oven: A scorching hot oven is a must. Pizza ovens that hit high temps quickly are ideal. They give you that crispy, chewy crust while locking in all the flavors.

  • Attention to Timing: Timing can make or break your pizza. Overcooked? It’s a cracker. Undercooked? It’s doughy. Skilled pizza makers know just when to pull it out for that perfect bite.

  • Passion and Skill: You can’t fake passion. Great pizza makers know their dough, their toppings, and their ovens inside out. Their love for pizza shines through in every slice.

Remember, while some pizza places may have similar tasting pizzas, it’s a mix of standardized recipes, ingredient sourcing, cooking methods, training, and customer preferences that make each one unique (Quora).

Whether you’re a fan of the classic Neapolitan or you crave a hearty deep-dish, pizza making is a delicious blend of flavors, techniques, and creativity. So next time you bite into a slice, take a moment to appreciate the skill and passion that went into making it.