Raleigh’s Pizza Gems

Mellow Mushroom Raleigh: Tripadvisor’s Top Pick

If you’re hunting for the best pizza in Raleigh, Mellow Mushroom Raleigh is where you need to be. Tripadvisor ranks it as the top pizza spot in the city (Stacker). Walking in, you’re hit with a groovy 1970s vibe that’s both nostalgic and fun.

But let’s get to the good stuff: the pizza. Mellow Mushroom serves up a variety of pies that cater to all tastes. Whether you’re a fan of the classic cheese or want to try something adventurous like the “Holy Shiitake Pie,” there’s something for everyone. The crust is a perfect mix of chewy and crispy, making each bite a joy.

Here’s a quick look at some of their popular options:

Pizza TypePrice (Medium)
Cheese Pizza$12.99
Pepperoni Pizza$14.99
Holy Shiitake Pie$18.99
Kosmic Karma$17.99

If you’re in Raleigh and craving a slice that’s out of this world, Mellow Mushroom is your go-to spot. Curious about top-rated pizzas in other cities? Check out the best pizza in Chicago or the best pizza in Brooklyn.

Trophy Brewing and Pizza: A Close Second

Next up is Trophy Brewing and Pizza, a hidden gem with a laid-back vibe and mouthwatering pizzas. Tripadvisor lists it as the second highest-rated pizza restaurant in Raleigh (Stacker).

Trophy Brewing and Pizza combines craft beer with exceptional pizza. The “Most Loyal” pizza, topped with roasted garlic, mozzarella, and pepperoni, is a fan favorite. For something more exotic, try the “Local Celebrity” with fig preserves, prosciutto, and arugula.

Here’s a peek at their top pizzas:

Pizza TypePrice (Small)
Most Loyal$15.00
Local Celebrity$16.00
Farmer’s Market$16.00

Pair your pizza with one of their signature brews, and you’re in for a treat. Trophy Brewing and Pizza is perfect for anyone looking to enjoy Raleigh’s pizza scene. If you ever find yourself in other cities, don’t miss out on the best pizza in Boston or the best pizza in Houston.

For more hidden gems and unique pizza experiences, keep exploring Raleigh’s pizza paradise. And if you’re interested in the top pizza spots in other cities, check out our articles on the best pizza in Las Vegas and the best pizza in Miami.

Raleigh’s Diverse Pizza Scene

Raleigh’s pizza scene is as varied as it is delicious. From wood-fired wonders to organic delights, there’s something for every pizza lover. Let’s check out three standout spots that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza: A Local Favorite

I can’t talk about the best pizza in Raleigh without mentioning Brixx Wood Fired Pizza. This place is a local favorite, and for good reason. Their pizzas are cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven, giving them that irresistible smoky flavor. According to Stacker, Brixx is one of the highest-rated pizza joints in town.

MargheritaFresh mozzarella, Roma tomatoes, basil$10.95
BBQ ChickenGrilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onions$11.95
Sausage & Spicy HoneySausage, red pepper flakes, honey$12.95

Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Margherita or something a bit more adventurous like their Sausage & Spicy Honey, Brixx has you covered.

Lilly’s Pizza: Organic and Artisanal Delights

Located in the historic Five Points neighborhood, Lilly’s Pizza is a must-visit for anyone who appreciates fresh, organic ingredients. Their made-from-scratch pizzas are a hit among locals and visitors alike. According to Stacker, Lilly’s offers a variety of specialty pizzas as well as vegetarian and vegan options.

The BuddhaSpinach, mushrooms, tofu, sesame seeds$13.95
The GreekFeta, Kalamata olives, artichokes$14.95
The Big StarPepperoni, sausage, green peppers$15.95

Whether you’re a meat lover or a veggie enthusiast, Lilly’s has something for everyone. Plus, their commitment to using local and organic ingredients makes every bite feel like a responsible choice.

Your Pie: Craft Your Own Pizza Adventure

If you’re the type who likes to call the shots, Your Pie is your dream come true. This place lets you craft your own pizza adventure by choosing from a variety of toppings and sauces (Stacker). It’s like being a pizza chef without all the hard work.

SaucesMarinara, Alfredo, BBQ
CheesesMozzarella, Feta, Vegan Cheese
ProteinsPepperoni, Chicken, Tofu
VeggiesSpinach, Mushrooms, Olives

The customization options are endless, making it a perfect spot for picky eaters or those with dietary restrictions. Don’t forget to check out their other pizza offerings if you’re ever in the mood for a pizza adventure outside of Raleigh.

So, whether you’re in the mood for a wood-fired classic, an organic delight, or a DIY masterpiece, Raleigh’s diverse pizza scene has something to satisfy your cravings. For more top pizza spots, check out our list of the best pizza in the world.

Hidden Pizza Treasures in Raleigh

On my quest for the best pizza in Raleigh, I stumbled upon some hidden gems that every pizza enthusiast should visit. Let’s check out three must-try spots that offer unique and mouth-watering experiences.

ACME Pizza: Chicago-Style Excellence

ACME Pizza, specializing in authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, is a standout in the Raleigh area. With locations in Holly Springs and Morrisville, this pizzeria has won multiple awards, making it a top contender for the best pizza in Raleigh. Opened in 2013 by Gwynn and JP LaRussa, ACME Pizza is known for carefully hand-selecting and assembling every ingredient in their recipes. Their dedication to quality shines through in every bite.

StyleChicago Deep-Dish
LocationsHolly Springs, Morrisville
OwnersGwynn and JP LaRussa
AwardsMultiple Best Pizza Awards

For those who crave a hearty, cheesy, and filling pizza, ACME Pizza is a must-visit. Check out their menu and prepare for a flavor explosion.

Frank’s Pizza: A Thirty-Year Legacy

Frank’s Pizza, located near Alamo Drafthouse Cinema in East Raleigh, has been a beloved pizza joint for over thirty years. Known for its hand-tossed pizzas made with fresh dough and homemade sauce, Frank’s Pizza has built a reputation as one of Raleigh’s best. Beyond pizza, they offer a variety of delicious items, including Philly cheesesteaks and hoagies.

LocationEast Raleigh
Years in Business30+
Known ForFresh Dough, Homemade Sauce
Additional OfferingsPhilly Cheesesteaks, Hoagies

With a legacy that spans decades, Frank’s Pizza is a testament to the timeless love for classic, well-made pizza. If you’re in the area, don’t miss out on this iconic spot.

Tony’s Pizza vs. Sergio’s Pizza: New York-Style Showdown

In Raleigh, the battle for the best New York-style pizza is fierce, and two contenders stand out: Tony’s Pizza and Sergio’s Pizza. Both offer thin, crispy crusts and the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, but each has its unique flair.

AspectTony’s PizzaSergio’s Pizza
StyleNew York-StyleNew York-Style
CrustThin, CrispyThin, Crispy
Cheese-to-Sauce RatioPerfectPerfect
Unique FlairFamily RecipesInnovative Toppings

For a true New York-style experience, deciding between Tony’s and Sergio’s can be tough. Why not try both and pick your favorite?

Exploring these hidden pizza treasures in Raleigh has been a delicious adventure. From the deep-dish excellence at ACME Pizza to the enduring legacy of Frank’s Pizza, and the New York-style showdown between Tony’s and Sergio’s, Raleigh offers a diverse and delectable pizza scene. For more pizza adventures, check out best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and best pizza in Boston.

Neapolitan Pizza Paradise

When it comes to Neapolitan pizza, Raleigh has some real gems. Here are two spots you shouldn’t miss if you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Raleigh.

Pizza La Stella: Authentic Italian Experience

I stumbled upon Pizza La Stella, nestled right in downtown Raleigh. This place doesn’t just make pizza; it transports you straight to Naples. They’ve got an oven imported directly from Naples, and they use ingredients straight from Italy (PullOverAndLetMeOut).

Here’s a little breakdown to whet your appetite:

OvenImported from Naples
IngredientsImported from Italy
StyleAuthentic Neapolitan

If you’re a purist looking for a slice of Italy in Raleigh, Pizza La Stella is your go-to spot.

Pizzeria Toro: Seasonal Toppings Galore

In the heart of Durham, a short drive from Raleigh, Pizzeria Toro pops up on every pizza lover’s radar. These folks know how to make a pie that’s both creative and delicious. They offer a variety of red and white-sauced pizzas, and trust me, you’ll want to ask for the extra side of their house-made red chili oil (Eater Carolinas).

Some of their fan-favorite pizzas include:

Prosciutto CottoOlives and Asiago (Red Sauce)
Soft Egg PizzaTrumpet Mushrooms, Arugula, and Parmesan (White Sauce)

If you’re in the mood for a pizza adventure, Pizzeria Toro’s seasonal toppings will keep you coming back for more.

For more pizza explorations, check out the best pizza in other cities like best pizza in Brooklyn or best pizza in Chicago.

Raleigh’s Unique Pizza Offerings

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Raleigh, sometimes you have to think outside the (pizza) box. In this section, I’ll take you through two of Raleigh’s most unique pizza spots, each offering something a bit different from your average pie.

Sofia’s Pizza: A Flavor Explosion

Sofia’s Pizza in East Durham isn’t just a pizzeria; it’s a culinary adventure. Known for their affordable prices and unique herbed crust, Sofia’s has quickly gained a loyal following. One of their standout creations is the East Durham pie, a delightful combination of applewood smoked bacon, collard greens, and serrano peppers (Eater Carolinas). Trust me, your taste buds will thank you for this spicy, smoky, and savory masterpiece.

Benchwarmers Bagels: The Detroit-Style Surprise

If you think bagels and pizza have nothing in common, think again. Benchwarmers Bagels, renowned for their wood-fired bagels, also dabbles in the art of Detroit-style pizza. Available on Thursdays and Fridays from 5:30pm-9pm, this thick, cheesy, rectangular pizza is an absolute must-try (Visit Raleigh).

The crust is where the magic happens—crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and loaded with cheese that caramelizes at the edges. You can grab a whole pie or just a slice, but either way, you’ll be dreaming about that crust for days.

Pizza SpotSpecialtyAvailability
Sofia’s PizzaEast Durham PieDaily
Benchwarmers BagelsDetroit-Style PizzaThurs-Fri, 5:30pm-9pm

These unique offerings are what make Raleigh’s pizza scene so exciting. Whether you’re in the mood for a flavor explosion at Sofia’s or a Detroit-style surprise at Benchwarmers Bagels, there’s something for every pizza lover. For more on Raleigh’s pizza gems, check out our guide to Raleigh’s best pizza.

Classic Pizzerias with a Twist

Poole’side Pies: A Chef’s Artistry

When I first walked into Poole’side Pies, I knew I was in for a treat. This Neapolitan-style pizzeria, opened in the summer of 2019 by James Beard award-winning chef Ashley Christensen, is a slice of heaven. The ambiance? Pure pizza bliss. The thin-crust pizzas are cooked at more than 800 degrees in a wood-fired oven, giving them that perfect charred edge and chewy center.

The dough, made from local flour, is a masterpiece in itself. The sauce? Organic Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes, bursting with flavor. And the cheese, you ask? House-made mozzarella. Yes, you heard that right. It’s like a symphony of flavors dancing on your taste buds (Visit Raleigh).

CrustThin, charred edge, chewy center
SauceOrganic Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes
CheeseHouse-made mozzarella
Oven Temperature800+ degrees

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Raleigh, Poole’side Pies should definitely be on your list. For more unique pizza offerings in Raleigh, check out our section on Raleigh’s Unique Pizza Offerings.

Gino’s Pizza: The New York Nostalgia

Ah, Gino’s Pizza. Stepping into Gino’s is like taking a quick trip to New York without leaving Raleigh. Known for its authentic New York-style pizza, this spot serves generous pies with vine-ripe fresh sauce and a crust browned to a crackling finish. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you want to fold it up and eat it on the go, just like they do in the Big Apple.

The lunch specials are a steal, with two one-topping slices and a drink for just over $5. Gino’s knows how to keep it real and keep it delicious (Visit Raleigh).

CrustBrowned to a crackling finish
SauceVine-ripe fresh
Lunch SpecialTwo one-topping slices + drink for $5.25

For those nostalgic for a slice of New York, Gino’s Pizza is a must-visit. If you’re curious about other top pizza destinations, don’t miss our deep dives into the best pizza in Brooklyn and best pizza in Manhattan.

These pizzerias are just a taste of what Raleigh has to offer. Whether you’re a fan of the artisanal touch at Poole’side Pies or the New York classic at Gino’s, Raleigh’s pizza scene has something for every pizza lover. For more hidden gems and unique pizza spots, explore our sections on Raleigh’s Unique Pizza Offerings and Hidden Pizza Treasures in Raleigh.