Omaha’s Pizza Scene

Best Pizza Rankings

My hunt for the best pizza in Omaha has led to some delicious finds. Here are the top spots that made my taste buds sing.

RankPizza PlaceHighlight
1Pitch PizzeriaLight, airy crust with creative options like buffalo chicken and Thai chicken (Official Omaha Pizza Rankings)
2Piezon’s PizzeriaCustomizable pizzas with a crisp crust and tangy sauce (Official Omaha Pizza Rankings)
3Noli’s PizzeriaUses New York tap water for the dough, perfect char from a 900-degree oven (Official Omaha Pizza Rankings)
4Dante PizzeriaBest sauce in Omaha, wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies (Official Omaha Pizza Rankings)
5Virtuoso PizzeriaHuge portions, crispy pepperoni cups (Official Omaha Pizza Rankings)

Pizza Joints Overview

Omaha’s pizza scene is a tasty adventure. Here’s a quick look at the top pizza joints that made my list:

  1. Pitch Pizzeria: This place is a dream for those who love a light and airy crust. Their creative toppings like buffalo chicken and Thai chicken are simply divine. It’s no wonder Pitch Pizzeria clinches the top spot in my rankings.

  2. Piezon’s Pizzeria: Customization is the name of the game here. With 13 original pizzas and 27 ingredients to mix and match, the possibilities are endless. The Hos pizza, loaded with pepperoni, Canadian bacon, hamburger, and sausage, is a meat lover’s paradise.

  3. Noli’s Pizzeria: The secret ingredient? New York tap water! This gives their crust an unmatched brilliance. Cooked in a 900-degree oven for just 60 seconds, the pizzas come out with a perfect char and quick service to boot.

  4. Dante Pizzeria: If you crave a strong tomato flavor balanced by sweetness, Dante’s sauce is the best in Omaha. Their wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pies feature locally sourced ingredients and toppings like Italian sausage and soppressata that hit it out of the park.

  5. Virtuoso Pizzeria: Known for their generous portions, Virtuoso’s crispy pepperoni cups are the star of the show. The thin but flavorful crust and minimalist cheese approach let the toppings truly shine.

For more pizza adventures, check out other cities like best pizza in Chicago or best pizza in Brooklyn. My pizza quest continues, but for now, Omaha has set the bar high.

Top Pizza Places in Omaha

In my quest for the best pizza in Omaha, I’ve encountered some truly exceptional pizzerias. Here are my top picks that you absolutely must try.

Pitch Pizzeria

Ranked as the best pizza place in Omaha, Pitch Pizzeria is a haven for pizza lovers. The light and airy crust is the perfect base for their plentiful and fresh toppings. Creative options like buffalo chicken and Thai chicken add a unique twist to the traditional pie. If you’re looking for a pizza that combines creativity with quality, Pitch Pizzeria is your go-to spot.

CrustLight and airy
ToppingsPlentiful and fresh
SpecialtiesBuffalo chicken, Thai chicken

Piezon’s Pizzeria

Coming in second, Piezon’s Pizzeria offers a level of customization that is hard to beat. With 13 original pizzas and 27 ingredients, you can create your perfect pie. The crisp and firm crust, tangy sauce, and star-quality toppings make this place a must-visit. The “Hos” pizza, topped with pepperoni, Canadian bacon, hamburger, and sausage, is highly recommended.

CrustCrisp and firm
ToppingsPepperoni, Canadian bacon, hamburger, sausage

Noli’s Pizzeria

Ranked third, Noli’s Pizzeria brings a slice of New York to Omaha with its use of New York tap water for the dough. The result is a crust that is nothing short of brilliant. Cooked in a 900-degree oven for just 60 seconds, the pizzas have a perfect char and quick service. The slightly sweet sauce complements the plentiful toppings beautifully (Official Omaha Pizza Rankings).

CrustMade with New York tap water
Cooking900-degree oven, 60 seconds
SauceSlightly sweet

Dante Pizzeria

Dante Pizzeria, ranked fourth, is a gem for those who appreciate a strong tomato flavor in their pizza sauce. The wood-fired approach produces Neapolitan-style pies with local ingredients. The Italian sausage and soppressata are particularly noteworthy, making every bite a delight (Official Omaha Pizza Rankings).

SauceStrong tomato flavor
ToppingsItalian sausage, soppressata

Virtuoso Pizzeria

Virtuoso Pizzeria, ranked fifth, is known for its gigantic portions and those amazing pepperonis that curl up into crispy, salty cups in the oven. The crust is thin but flavorful, and the minimalist approach to cheese allows the toppings to shine. It’s a close contender with Noli’s and definitely worth a visit.

PepperoniCrispy cups
CrustThin but flavorful

For more pizza adventures, check out our guides on the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and even the best pizza in the world. Happy eating!

Unique Pizza Creations

Embarking on my quest for the best pizza in Omaha, I discovered some truly unique pizza creations that left my taste buds dancing. Here are five standout pizzas that you absolutely must try.

Hot Honey Pizza at Virtuoso Pizzeria

At Virtuoso Pizzeria, the Hot Honey Pizza is an experience in itself. Imagine an enormous slice with a crust that maintains its integrity and boasts an airy texture. The stone-baking process leaves charming charring spots, while the sweet and acidic sauce achieves a perfect balance. This pizza is a must-try for anyone who appreciates a blend of sweet and spicy flavors (Restaurant Hoppen).

Slice SizeEnormous
CrustAiry with charring spots
SauceWell-balanced sweet and acidic

Honeypeno Pizza at Izzy’s Pizza

Izzy’s Pizza offers the Honeypeno Pizza, which takes Detroit-style pizza to a whole new level. This pizza features a crunchy, caramelized cheese crust, buttery dough, sweet tomato sauce, Char-N-Cup pepperonis, pickled jalapenos, and a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey. The combination of sweet and heat flavors is nothing short of brilliant (Restaurant Hoppen).

CrustCrunchy, caramelized cheese crust
ToppingsChar-N-Cup pepperonis, pickled jalapenos, Mike’s Hot Honey

Rustica Pizza at Dolomiti

Dolomiti’s Rustica Pizza is a masterpiece with a unique dough that combines the best of Neapolitan and New York pizza styles. Featuring smoky roasted broccolini, gooey mozzarella, Italian sausage, and a sweet honey drizzle, this pizza is a flavor explosion. The confit garlic adds a sweet, creamy touch that takes each bite to the next level (Restaurant Hoppen).

DoughMix of Neapolitan and New York styles
ToppingsRoasted broccolini, mozzarella, Italian sausage, honey drizzle
Special IngredientConfit garlic

Authentic Neapolitan Pizza at Dante

Dante is the only certified restaurant in Omaha serving authentic, wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas. Their Margherita pizza stands out with a bouncy, chewy crust, airy dough pockets, and charred portions from the wood-burning oven. The sweet San Marzano base sauce, gooey fresh mozzarella, and basil toppings create a classic yet extraordinary experience.

CrustBouncy, chewy with airy pockets
SauceSweet San Marzano
ToppingsFresh mozzarella, basil

Pepperoni Pizza at Lyle’s Pizzeria

Lyle’s Pizzeria offers a Pepperoni Pizza that is a true delight. Featuring a thin and crispy sourdough crust, the quality ingredients and tangy sauce balance perfectly with the salty and fatty pepperoni. The dough’s structure and integrity, with its distinct sourdough tang, make this pizza a standout.

CrustThin, crispy sourdough
ToppingsSalty, fatty pepperoni

These unique pizza creations are just a glimpse into the vibrant pizza scene in Omaha. For more pizza adventures, check out our guides to the best pizza in Chicago and the best pizza in Brooklyn.

Omaha’s Pizza Events

Omaha is no stranger to pizza events, and let me tell you, these are the kind of gatherings where pizza dreams come true. Here’s a slice of what you can expect from the city’s top pizza events.

Omaha’s Largest Pizza Review

Imagine over 130 pizza lovers crammed into Jake’s Cigars & Spirits in Benson, devouring 33 pizzas in less than an hour. Yes, that’s exactly what happened at Omaha’s Largest Pizza Review, Ever. Participating pizzerias included La Casa Pizzeria, Mangia Italiana, Don Carmelo’s Pizzeria, Orsi’s Italian Bakery, Lo Sole Mio, Pudgy’s Pizzeria, Mama’s Pizza, Johnny Sortino’s Pizza Parlor, Frank’s Pizzeria, Caniglia’s Venice Inn, and Sgt. Peffer’s Café Italiana. It was a pizza frenzy of epic proportions.

La Casa PizzeriaOmaha
Mangia ItalianaOmaha
Don Carmelo’s PizzeriaOmaha
Orsi’s Italian BakeryOmaha
Lo Sole MioOmaha
Pudgy’s PizzeriaOmaha
Mama’s PizzaOmaha
Johnny Sortino’s Pizza ParlorOmaha
Frank’s PizzeriaOmaha
Caniglia’s Venice InnOmaha
Sgt. Peffer’s Café ItalianaOmaha

People’s Choice Awards

The People’s Choice Award for the best pizza in Omaha was a tight race. Mangia Italiana, La Casa Pizzeria, and Lo Sole Mio came out on top, but here’s the kicker: every participating restaurant received at least one vote for first place. Apparently, Omaha residents have a lot of love to give to their pizza joints.

Judge’s Choice Awards

The Judge’s Choice Awards were a bit more selective. La Casa Pizzeria, Pudgy’s Pizzeria, Mama’s Pizza, and Sgt. Peffer’s Café Italiana took home the honors. Judges scored the pizzas on a ten-point scale and provided insightful comments on each slice. Clearly, these judges were serious about their pizza.

RestaurantJudge’s Score (out of 10)
La Casa Pizzeria9.5
Pudgy’s Pizzeria9.2
Mama’s Pizza9.0
Sgt. Peffer’s Café Italiana8.8

Publisher’s Pick

The Publisher’s Pick was a sentimental favorite: Orsi’s Italian Bakery. The publisher had a personal history with this pizzeria, making it a heartwarming choice. Sometimes, the best pizza isn’t just about the taste—it’s about the memories.

If you’re a pizza fanatic, Omaha’s pizza events are not to be missed. And if you’re ever curious about the best pizza in other cities, check out our articles on the best pizza in chicago, best pizza in brooklyn, and many more.

Noteworthy Pizza Restaurants

Embarking on my pizza journey through Omaha, I discovered some absolute gems that deserve special mention. Each of these spots has its own unique charm and a slice that will make you say “Mama mia!”

Orsi’s Italian Bakery & Pizzeria

Orsi’s Italian Bakery & Pizzeria stands tall as the highest-rated pizza restaurant in Omaha, according to Tripadvisor. With its old-school vibe and mouth-watering offerings, it’s no wonder this place is a local favorite. The bakery-style pizza crust gives a delightful crunch, while the toppings are generous and fresh. If you’re in the mood for a classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, Orsi’s has got you covered.

Zio’s Pizzeria

Zio’s Pizzeria is another top contender in Omaha’s pizza scene. Known for their New York-style pizza, Zio’s offers gigantic slices that are perfect for folding and devouring. Their sauce has a tangy, slightly sweet flavor that pairs beautifully with the gooey cheese and crispy crust. It’s no surprise that Zio’s holds a prominent position among the top five highest-rated pizza places in the city (Stacker).

Mangia Italiana

Mangia Italiana brings a touch of authenticity to Omaha with its traditional recipes and hearty servings. This spot is perfect for those who crave a slice that feels like a warm hug from Nonna. The crust is perfectly chewy, the sauce rich and flavorful, and the toppings are always fresh. Mangia Italiana is a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine Italian pizza experience. It’s so good, you’ll be saying “mangia, mangia” with every bite!

La Casa Pizzeria

La Casa Pizzeria has been serving up delicious pies since 1953, making it one of Omaha’s beloved institutions. Their unique rectangular pizzas are a delightful departure from the traditional round ones. The crust is thin and crispy, and the cheese blend is nothing short of perfection. Whether you’re a fan of classic toppings or looking to try something new, La Casa’s extensive menu has something for everyone.

Oscar’s Pizza and Sports Grille

Oscar’s Pizza and Sports Grille combines two of the greatest things in life: pizza and sports. This lively spot is perfect for catching a game while enjoying a slice (or five). Their pizza is hearty, with a thick crust that’s crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings are plentiful, and the atmosphere is always buzzing. If you’re looking for a fun place to enjoy some pizza and cheer on your favorite team, Oscar’s is the place to be.

Each of these noteworthy pizza joints brings something special to the table, making them essential stops on your quest for the best pizza in Omaha. If you’re ever in the mood for a pizza adventure, don’t forget to check out our guides to the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and more!