Pizza Paradise in Myrtle Beach

If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, I’ve done the legwork (and the taste tests) for you. Here are my top picks for a pizza paradise in this beachside town.

Vicini’s Restaurant and Pizza

Vicini’s is a hidden treasure for pizza lovers. Their pizzas are a perfect mix of crust, sauce, and toppings. Even their appetizers, like fried calamari and mussels with chardonnay sauce, get rave reviews. If you’re after a cozy spot with a touch of Italian charm, this is it.

DishPrice
Margherita Pizza$12
Fried Calamari$9
Mussels with Chardonnay Sauce$10

AJ’s Pizza Spotlights

AJ’s Pizza is a local favorite, known for serving up some of the best pizza and wings in town. The reviews are glowing, and I can personally vouch for their crispy, chewy delight. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a feast, AJ’s never disappoints.

DishPrice
Cheese Pizza$10
Pepperoni Pizza$11
Wings (10 pcs)$8

Melt: A Pizza Gem

Melt is a place that has truly earned its reputation. Their ‘Margherita’ pizza is a must-try, and it’s so good you’ll be tempted to order seconds. The relaxed atmosphere makes it a perfect spot to unwind and enjoy a slice or two.

DishPrice
Margherita Pizza$13
BBQ Chicken Pizza$14
Garlic Knots$5

Hot Tomato Italian Delights

Hot Tomato Italian Restaurant & Brick Oven is another spot that deserves a visit. Their pizza is exceptional, with a perfect blend of flavors that will leave you wanting more. One reviewer even suggested skipping the salad and diving straight into their pizza and pasta offerings. I couldn’t agree more.

DishPrice
Meat Lovers Pizza$15
Veggie Pizza$12
Spaghetti & Meatballs$11

Mama Mia’s Pizza Haven

Mama Mia Pizzeria is a haven for pizza enthusiasts. With a wide selection of pizzas and various toppings to choose from, there’s something for everyone. They also offer great discounts through coupons on their website, making it an affordable and tasty option.

DishPrice
Hawaiian Pizza$12
Supreme Pizza$14
Caesar Salad$6

So, if you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, these spots are sure to satisfy your cravings. Be sure to check out more of my pizza adventures in other cities, like the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, or even the best pizza in Vegas. Happy eating, my fellow pizza lovers!

Top-Rated Pizza Joints

When it comes to the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, these top-rated spots have been turning heads and satisfying cravings. Let’s dig into the doughy goodness!

AJ’s Pizza Reigns Supreme

Alright, folks, if you haven’t been to AJ’s Pizza, you are missing out on a slice of heaven. According to Tripadvisor, AJ’s is the highest-rated pizza spot in Myrtle Beach with a stellar 4.5 out of 5 based on 308 reviews. The food is fantastic, the service is top-notch, and the atmosphere is just right for a pizza indulgence. You might just find me there, stuffing my face with a crispy, chewy delight.

Vicini’s Italian Excellence

Next up, Vicini’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria. This gem is also rated 4.5 out of 5 on Tripadvisor, based on 246 reviews. Vicini’s excels in food, service, and value. I mean, where else can you find pizza that feels like a hug from an Italian grandmother? For all my fellow pizza lovers, Vicini’s is a must-visit.

Hot Tomato’s Pizza Perfection

Hot Tomato is where pizza dreams come true. Holding the third position among Myrtle Beach pizza joints, it boasts a 4.5 out of 5 rating based on 678 reviews. This place is a crowd-pleaser, even if detailed ratings weren’t available. Trust me, their pizza will have you coming back for more slices than you can count.

Little Italy’s Authenticity

Little Italy is like taking a mini-vacation to Naples without leaving Myrtle Beach. This spot secured the fourth spot with a 4.5 out of 5 rating from 346 reviews. Food, service, value, and atmosphere – Little Italy nails them all. If you want a true Italian pizza experience, this is the place to be.

Capriccio’s Traditional Touch

Capriccio rounds out our top five pizza joints with a fantastic 4.5 out of 5 rating based on 524 reviews. This spot excels in all the right categories: food, service, value, and atmosphere. If you’re craving traditional pizza with a touch of class, Capriccio is your destination.

Pizza JointRatingReviews
AJ’s Pizza4.5308
Vicini’s4.5246
Hot Tomato4.5678
Little Italy4.5346
Capriccio4.5524

For more about pizza in other cities, check out the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and best pizza in Boston. If you’re planning a trip, don’t miss the best pizza in Las Vegas and best pizza in Miami.

Unique Pizza Experiences

Mellow Mushroom’s Creative Flair

When I think of Mellow Mushroom, I picture a quirky, fun atmosphere perfect for families and pizza lovers alike. Their stone-baked pizza pies are a masterpiece, with buttery parmesan crusts that add a delightful crunch to every bite. Let’s not forget their extensive selection of craft beers, sandwiches, and salads that complement the pizza experience. With an average of four stars from 339 reviews, it’s clear that Mellow Mushroom is a hit in Myrtle Beach.

Ultimate California Pizza Highlights

Ultimate California Pizza (UCP) is a local gem that stands out with its diverse menu of pizzas, subs, and more. Whether you’re dining in or carrying out, UCP never disappoints. The franchise has made a name for itself along the coast, offering a variety of delicious options that keep customers coming back for more.

California Pizza’s Local Charm

Located on the north end of Myrtle Beach, California Pizza brings a touch of local charm with its focus on locally sourced ingredients. Their thin-crust pizzas are baked to perfection in a brick oven, providing a crispy yet chewy texture that’s hard to resist. Whether you choose to dine in or carry out, California Pizza ensures a satisfying experience.

Vicini’s Rainbow Harbor Gem

Vicini’s in Rainbow Harbor offers a small, intimate setting that enhances the overall pizza experience. Known for its crisp crust, tangy sauce, and perfect cheese blend, Vicini’s has earned a reputation for excellence. This cozy spot is ideal for those looking to enjoy some of the best pizza in Myrtle Beach in a relaxed environment.

Mellow Mushroom’s Artsy Vibes

Mellow Mushroom isn’t just about great pizza; it’s also about the atmosphere. The artsy vibes and unique decor make dining here a memorable experience. The stone-baked pizzas are not only delicious but also visually appealing, adding to the overall charm of the place. It’s no wonder this spot is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Here’s a quick comparison of these unique pizza spots:

Pizza SpotUnique FeatureNotable Menu Items
Mellow MushroomCreative stone-baked pizzas, artsy atmosphereButtery parmesan crust pizza, craft beers
Ultimate California PizzaDiverse menu, local franchisePizzas, subs
California PizzaLocally sourced ingredients, brick oven pizzaThin-crust pizzas
Vicini’s Rainbow HarborIntimate setting, crisp crustCheese blend, tangy sauce

For more pizza adventures, check out our articles on the best pizza in Chicago and the best pizza in Brooklyn.

Local Favorites & Reviews

Scotto’s Homey Feel

Imagine walking into Scotto’s and being greeted by the aroma of freshly baked pizza. This place has four and a half stars out of 47 reviews, making it a local gem for those craving a quick, cheesy delight. Reviewers from New York have claimed that Scotto’s makes them feel right at home, which is a high compliment considering the Big Apple’s pizza reputation.

CriteriaRating
Overall Rating4.5/5
Number of Reviews47
Cheese Generosity5/5
Speed of Service4/5

Little Italy’s True Italian Taste

Little Italy is like stepping into a slice of Italy without the airfare. This place has an average of four and a half stars out of 373 reviews. One reviewer, hailing from a family with Italian roots, claimed that the food was so genuinely Italian, it knocked them off their chair. If that’s not an endorsement, I don’t know what is.

CriteriaRating
Overall Rating4.5/5
Number of Reviews373
Authenticity5/5
Atmosphere4.5/5

AJ’s Pizza’s Crispy & Chewy Delight

AJ’s Pizza is a fan favorite for those who love a good crust. With an average of four and a half stars from more than 230 reviewers, this place is known for its crispy and chewy crust, tangy and spicy sauce, and top-notch mozzarella cheese. It’s like a pizza party in your mouth, and everyone’s invited.

CriteriaRating
Overall Rating4.5/5
Number of Reviews230+
Crust Quality5/5
Sauce Flavor4.5/5

Vicini’s Intimate & Homey Atmosphere

Vicini’s is the kind of place that makes you feel like you’ve been invited into someone’s cozy kitchen. Holding an average of four and a half stars from 234 reviewers, Vicini’s is praised for its crispness, cheese, and sweet sauce. The intimate and homey atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a quiet meal with exceptional pizza.

CriteriaRating
Overall Rating4.5/5
Number of Reviews234
Crispness5/5
Atmosphere5/5

Corrado’s Pizza Excellence

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, Corrado’s Pizza is your go-to place. With a stellar rating of 4.8/5 based on 42 reviews, Corrado’s ranks as the top pizza joint in town. Reviewers rave about the quality, flavor, and overall excellence of their pizzas.

CriteriaRating
Overall Rating4.8/5
Number of Reviews42
Quality5/5
Flavor5/5

For more pizza adventures, check out our articles on the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and best pizza in Boston.

Myrtle Beach Pizza Rankings

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Myrtle Beach, I embarked on a cheesy adventure to uncover the top contenders. Here are my top picks, ranked for your pizza-loving pleasure.

Corrado’s Dominance

Corrado’s Pizza takes the crown with an impressive rating of 4.8/5 from 42 reviews. This pizzeria is known for its mouthwatering pies and unbeatable flavor. Trust me, their pizza is like a slice of heaven.

RestaurantRatingReviews
Corrado’s Pizza4.842

Little Italy’s Endearing Appeal

Little Italy holds a special place in my heart with a high rating of 4.4/5 based on 469 reviews. The authentic Italian taste and charming atmosphere make this spot a must-visit for any pizza aficionado.

RestaurantRatingReviews
Little Italy4.4469

Vicini’s Rave Reviews

Vicini’s Restaurant and Pizza is another gem in Myrtle Beach, boasting a score of 4.6/5 from 322 reviews. Their pizza is simply divine, and the cozy ambiance makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal.

RestaurantRatingReviews
Vicini’s4.6322

Toffino’s Deli & Bakery Charm

Toffino’s Italian Bakery & Deli is not just a bakery; it’s a pizza paradise with a rating of 4.4/5 from 481 reviews. Their pizzas are a delightful blend of fresh ingredients and authentic Italian flavors.

RestaurantRatingReviews
Toffino’s4.4481

AJ’s Pizza’s Stellar Reputation

AJ’s Pizza rounds out my top picks with a stellar rating of 4.5/5 from 411 reviews. Known for its crispy and chewy delight, AJ’s Pizza is a fan favorite and a must-try for any pizza lover.

RestaurantRatingReviews
AJ’s Pizza4.5411

If you’re ever in Myrtle Beach and craving a slice, these are the spots you need to check out. For more pizza adventures, you can explore the best pizza in Brooklyn, best pizza in Chicago, or even the best pizza in the world.