Flagstaff’s Pizza Paradise

Flagstaff, Arizona is a pizza lover’s dream come true. From classic pies to inventive creations, this town has something to satisfy every pizza craving. Let’s take a tasty tour of Flagstaff’s top pizza joints and the unique styles that make them special.

Must-Try Pizza Spots in Flagstaff

First up, we have Pizzicletta. This place is the brainchild of Caleb Schiff, a geologist who swapped rocks for dough after a cycling trip through Italy. His wood-fired pizzas are a slice of Italy right in Flagstaff. Pizzicletta has earned rave reviews for its dedication to authentic pizza-making.

Next, there’s Fat Olives. Known for its smoked salmon salad and creative pizza combos, this spot is a hit among locals and visitors alike. Fat Olives prides itself on using top-notch ingredients to craft pizzas that are both unique and delicious.

Unique Pizza Styles

Flagstaff isn’t just about traditional pizza; it also offers some unique styles that cater to all kinds of tastes. Take Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, for example. This place is famous for its New York-style pizza, complete with a thin, crispy crust and flavorful toppings. It’s a little slice of the Big Apple right here in Arizona.

If you’re into craft beer, Beaver Street Brewery is the spot for you. They serve up wood-fired pizzas that pair perfectly with their wide selection of brews. Try their BBQ chicken, prosciutto pear, or six-cheese pizza. They even have gluten-free and vegan options, so everyone can join the pizza party.

Flagstaff’s pizza scene is a culinary adventure waiting to happen. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or something a bit more adventurous, there’s a pizza here with your name on it. So, grab a friend, head to one of these hotspots, and enjoy some of the best pizza Arizona has to offer.

Pizzicletta: A Geologist’s Pizza Adventure

Looking for the best pizza in Flagstaff? Pizzicletta is the spot you don’t want to miss. Nestled in Flagstaff, Arizona, this cozy pizzeria blends wood-fired magic with Italian flair.

Wood-Fired Magic

Pizzicletta isn’t just any pizza joint. It’s the passion project of Caleb Schiff, a geologist who swapped rocks for dough after biking through Italy. Inspired by his journey, Caleb returned home with a mission: to master the art of pizza. The secret? A wood-fired oven that cranks out pizzas with crispy, chewy crusts and those irresistible charred edges.

The oven’s high heat cooks the pizzas quickly, locking in the freshness of the toppings. And that smoky aroma? It’s like a warm hug for your senses, making each bite a little slice of heaven.

Italian Roots, Flagstaff Flavor

Caleb’s Italian adventure wasn’t just about sightseeing. He soaked up the rich traditions of Italian pizza-making, bringing those flavors back to Flagstaff. The menu at Pizzicletta is a love letter to Italy, featuring both classic and creative toppings made from top-notch ingredients.

Whether you’re craving a traditional Margherita with fresh basil and mozzarella or something a bit more adventurous like arugula and prosciutto, Pizzicletta’s got you covered. Each pizza is a work of art, crafted with care and authenticity. It’s no wonder pizza lovers rave about this place.

Biting into a Pizzicletta pizza is like taking a trip to Naples or Rome, where pizza is more than food—it’s a way of life. The flavors, textures, and aromas all come together to create an unforgettable experience. Whether you’re a Flagstaff local or just passing through, Pizzicletta is a must-visit for any pizza fan.

Next up, we’ll check out other top pizza spots in Flagstaff. We’ll compare Pizzicletta with Fat Olives, and also dive into what makes Grimaldi’s Pizzeria and Lumberjack Pizza stand out. Stick around to uncover more pizza treasures in Flagstaff!

Flagstaff’s Best Pizza Joints

Got a pizza craving in Flagstaff, Arizona? You’re in luck! This town’s got some killer spots that’ll make your taste buds dance. Let’s check out two of the top-rated pizza places: Pizzicletta and Grimaldi’s Pizzeria.

Pizzicletta vs. Fat Olives

First up, Pizzicletta. This wood-fired gem is the brainchild of Caleb Schiff, a geologist who traded rocks for dough. His pizza obsession started during a cycling trip across Italy, and now he’s serving up pies that are pure art (Food & Wine). Each pizza is a masterpiece, cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven.

Then there’s Fat Olives, just a hop, skip, and a jump from Historic Downtown Flagstaff. This family-run spot is all about traditional Italian pizzas, using top-notch ingredients like ricotta, fennel sausage, and flour straight from Italy. They even caught the eye of Guy Fieri on the Food Network, who couldn’t get enough of their Kennai and Belgio Dolce pizzas.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria and Lumberjack Pizza

Next, we’ve got Grimaldi’s Pizzeria. Known for its coal-fired brick oven, Grimaldi’s is a big deal in Arizona. Their pizzas are made the old-school way with fresh ingredients, giving you a flavor explosion in every bite. The cozy vibe makes it a great spot to chow down on some seriously good pizza.

For a local twist, check out Lumberjack Pizza. This place is a local favorite, offering creative pizzas with toppings that nod to Flagstaff’s lumberjack roots. Whether you go for the Lumberjack Deluxe, the Black Bear, or the Paul Bunyan, you’re in for a treat.

So, whether you’re craving the Neapolitan-style goodness of Pizzicletta, the Italian flair of Fat Olives, the coal-fired magic of Grimaldi’s, or the local charm of Lumberjack Pizza, Flagstaff’s got you covered. Each spot has its own vibe and flavors, making sure pizza lovers have plenty to choose from.

Neighborhood Pizza Treasures

Flagstaff’s pizza scene is like a treasure hunt for your taste buds. Two standout spots that have locals and visitors raving are NiMarco’s Pizza and Beaver Street Brewery. Let’s dig into what makes these places special.

NiMarco’s Pizza

NiMarco’s Pizza, with its Downtown and Eastside locations, is a local favorite. Folks on Yelp can’t stop singing its praises. Whether you’re a classic Margherita fan or craving something different like BBQ Chicken or Prosciutto Pear, NiMarco’s has got you covered.

Their menu is a smorgasbord of flavors. You can stick to the classics or venture into unique territory. Either way, you’re in for a treat. The atmosphere is cozy, and the staff? Super friendly. It’s the kind of place where you feel right at home, even if it’s your first visit.

Beaver Street Brewery

Beaver Street Brewery isn’t just about great beer; their wood-fired pizzas are the stuff of legend. According to Flagstaff Arizona, their pizza menu is a hit with locals. From BBQ Chicken to Prosciutto Pear and even a Six Cheese option, there’s something for everyone. They also offer gluten-free and vegan options, so no one has to miss out.

The secret to their delicious pizzas? Quality ingredients and a wood-fired oven that gives each pie a perfect, crispy crust. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurous eater, Beaver Street Brewery will make your pizza dreams come true.

Both NiMarco’s and Beaver Street Brewery showcase the creativity and passion of Flagstaff’s culinary scene. If you find yourself in Flagstaff with a pizza craving, these spots are a must-visit.

For more pizza recommendations in other cities, check out our articles on the best pizza in Oklahoma City, Virginia Beach, Queens, Sarasota, Memphis, Key West, Pigeon Forge, Bronx, The Bronx, Des Moines, Reno, Grand Rapids, Ann Arbor, Madison, Michigan, Minnesota, Astoria, Boca Raton, Destin, Fort Myers, Long Beach, Oakland, Park City, Cape Coral, Tacoma, Breckenridge, Knoxville, Oceanside, Tulsa, Chattanooga, Traverse City, Pasadena, Sedona, Westchester, Charleston, Rochester, Baton Rouge, Berkeley, Fresno, Spokane, El Paso, Tallahassee, Gatlinburg, Jacksonville, Marco Island, the North End, Durham, Palm Desert, and Syracuse.

Fratelli Pizza: Flagstaff’s Favorite Slice

If you’re in Flagstaff and craving pizza, there’s one place that locals and visitors alike rave about: Fratelli Pizza. This joint has snagged the title of Best Pizza in the Arizona Daily Sun’s Best of Flagstaff for an incredible 21 out of the last 22 years. That’s not just luck—that’s a whole lot of deliciousness.

Why Fratelli Pizza Rocks

So, what makes Fratelli Pizza the go-to spot? It’s their relentless focus on quality. Not only have they been crowned Best Pizza, but they’ve also bagged the Best Overall Restaurant award. This isn’t just about pizza; it’s about a top-notch dining experience from start to finish (Arizona Daily Sun).

Co-owner Pete Schepper shared that they’ve doubled down on quality, making sure every pizza that comes out of their kitchen is top-tier. You can taste the dedication in every bite. It’s like they’ve got a secret sauce for success, and it’s not just the tomato kind.

The Secret Sauce: Quality and Experience

Fratelli Pizza doesn’t mess around when it comes to quality. Pete and the team even held a “pizza clinic” to fine-tune their recipes. They spent time in the kitchen, tweaking and perfecting every detail to make sure each pizza is a masterpiece. This hands-on approach shows just how committed they are to serving the best pizza in town (Arizona Daily Sun).

But it’s not just about the pizza; it’s also about the people. The general managers at Fratelli Pizza bring around 40 years of combined experience to the table. Their expertise and leadership are key ingredients in the recipe for success. It’s this solid foundation that keeps customers coming back for more.

So, if you find yourself in Flagstaff, do yourself a favor and grab a slice at Fratelli Pizza. With their unwavering commitment to quality and a dining experience that’s second to none, it’s no wonder they’re the best in town.

Why Everyone Loves Fratelli Pizza

Fratelli Pizza has become a local favorite in Flagstaff, and it’s not just by chance. Let’s break down what makes this place so special.

The “Pizza Clinic”

Fratelli Pizza’s secret sauce isn’t just in their recipes—it’s in their dedication to perfecting every pie. They run a “pizza clinic” where the owners and staff get hands-on to tweak and improve their pizzas. Co-owner Pete Schepper is often found in the kitchen, making sure each pizza is up to snuff. This relentless pursuit of perfection shows just how much they care about giving you the best pizza experience.

Leadership That Knows Its Stuff

Another big reason for Fratelli Pizza’s success is their top-notch management. Their general managers bring a whopping 40 years of combined experience to the table (Arizona Daily Sun). These folks know their pizza, from picking the freshest ingredients to making sure every slice is just right. Their expertise and eye for detail keep the quality consistently high, making Fratelli Pizza a go-to spot.

Thanks to their focus on quality and constant improvement, Fratelli Pizza has snagged the title of Best Pizza in Flagstaff and even Best Overall Restaurant. Their commitment to excellence and experienced leadership make every visit a treat, ensuring customers keep coming back for more.

Next up, let’s check out the pizza hotspots in Flagstaff and see what other tasty options this city has to offer.