Columbus Pizza Scene

Overview of Columbus Pizza

If there’s one thing I love about Columbus, it’s the pizza. The city is packed with pizza joints, both old and new, that cater to every kind of pizza lover. From classic favorites to innovative newcomers, there’s no shortage of options to satisfy any pizza craving. Whether you’re into thin crust, deep dish, or something in between, Columbus has got you covered (Experience Columbus).

One of the coolest things about Columbus pizza is its variety. You can find everything from New York Style to Chicago Deep Dish, and even the local favorite, Columbus Style pizza. This mix makes Columbus a true haven for pizza lovers, offering a taste of different pizza cultures all in one city.

Popular Pizza Styles in Columbus

Columbus is a melting pot of pizza styles, each with its own distinct characteristics. Here are some of the most popular styles you can find in the city:

Columbus Style Pizza

Columbus Style pizza is the city’s own creation. It features a thin crust, covered edge-to-edge with toppings, and cut into smaller squares. This style is perfect for those who love a crispy crust and generous toppings. Some notable spots for Columbus Style pizza include Iacono’s, Rubino’s, Villa Nova Ristorante, Tommy’s Pizza, Pizza House, Massey’s Pizza, and Donatos (Experience Columbus).

New York Style Pizza

New York Style pizza is known for its large, foldable slices and thin, yet chewy crust. In Columbus, you can find delicious New York Style pizzas at places like Mikey’s Late Night Slice, Natalie’s Coal Fired Pizza, Borgata Pizza Cafe, Harvest Pizzeria, Yellow Brick Pizza, and Adriatico’s.

Chicago Style Deep Dish

For those who prefer a pizza with more substance, Chicago Style Deep Dish is the way to go. This style features a thick, buttery crust and is loaded with cheese and toppings. Meister’s Bar in Grandview is a go-to spot for remarkable deep dish pizza options, where you can either build your own pie or choose from their signature selections (Experience Columbus).

Other Regional Styles

Columbus also embraces a variety of other regional styles, offering a wide range of options for pizza enthusiasts. These include:

  • Detroit Style: Known for its rectangular shape and thick, crispy crust.
  • Sicilian: A thick, square pizza with a fluffy, focaccia-like crust.
  • Rhode Island Style: Features a thick crust with a chewy texture.
  • New Haven Style Apizza: Known for its thin, charred crust and simple toppings.
  • Steubenville / Ohio Valley Style: A unique style where toppings are added after the pizza comes out of the oven.

With such a rich variety of pizza styles, Columbus truly has something for everyone. Whether you’re a fan of classic thin crust or adventurous enough to try the unique Ohio Valley Style, the best pizza in Columbus is just a bite away. For more on the best pizza spots in other cities, check out our articles on the best pizza in Chicago and the best pizza in Brooklyn.

Best Pizza Spots in Columbus

Pizza lovers, rejoice! I’ve scoured Columbus to bring you the absolute best spots to satisfy your pizza cravings. Each of these pizzerias offers a unique twist on everybody’s favorite dish. So, grab a napkin (or ten) because things are about to get cheesy.

Fibonacci’s Pizzeria

Fibonacci’s Pizzeria isn’t just a place; it’s an experience. Imagine enjoying a delicious pizza pie paired perfectly with a cold beer. That’s what you’ll get here. The buzz around town and Yelp reviews unanimously agree: Fibonacci’s is a must-visit for any pizza aficionado.

FeatureRating
Ambiance4.5/5
Pizza Quality4.7/5
Beer Selection4.6/5

Borgata Pizza Cafe

Dubbed “Truly the best pizza in Columbus,” Borgata Pizza Cafe enjoys a sterling reputation for its high-quality pies (Yelp). Whether you’re a fan of classic toppings or adventurous combinations, Borgata has something to satisfy every palate.

FeatureRating
Ambiance4.3/5
Pizza Quality4.8/5
Service4.5/5

Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza

Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza is the kind of place that makes you declare, “This is the best pizza I ever tasted!” Known for its generous toppings and flavor-packed sauce, Hounddog’s is a standout option for pizza enthusiasts in Columbus.

FeatureRating
Ambiance4.2/5
Pizza Quality4.9/5
Value for Money4.7/5

Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza

Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza is the darling of the campus crowd. Known as “Definitely the best pizza on campus,” it’s a go-to spot for students and pizza lovers alike (Yelp). Their New York-style slices are the stuff of legend.

FeatureRating
Ambiance4.1/5
Pizza Quality4.6/5
Student-Friendly4.9/5

Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery

Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery is where you go when you want the “Best pizza ever.” With fresh ingredients and a crispy, chewy dough, it’s a top choice for pizza in Columbus (Yelp). The bakery aspect adds a unique twist, offering delicious baked goods alongside their incredible pizzas.

FeatureRating
Ambiance4.4/5
Pizza Quality4.8/5
Fresh Ingredients4.7/5

Paulie Gee’s

Paulie Gee’s won the coveted title of best pizza in Columbus in 2023. Located in Short North, this place offers both Neapolitan-style and Detroit-style pizzas, fired up in a wood oven. Their dedication to top-notch ingredients and unique flavors has won over many fans (Columbus Underground).

FeatureRating
Ambiance4.6/5
Pizza Quality4.9/5
Unique Styles4.7/5

Craving more pizza adventures? Check out our articles on the best pizza in chicago, best pizza in brooklyn, and best pizza in boston for a cheesy tour across the country.

The Best Columbus Pizza of 2022

Harvest Pizzeria

Ladies and gents, I present to you the reigning champion of Columbus pizza: Harvest Pizzeria! Yes, you heard it right. Harvest Pizzeria has claimed the top spot for the best Columbus pizza of 2022 (Columbus Underground). If you haven’t tried it yet, what are you even doing with your life?

Harvest Pizzeria is renowned for its farm-to-table approach, using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that make each bite a symphony of flavors. Whether you’re into classic Margheritas or adventurous seasonal specials, their menu has got something to tickle your taste buds.

FeatureDetails
LocationMultiple locations in Columbus
SpecialtyFarm-to-table pizzas
Must-TrySpicy Yuma, Almond Pesto Pizza
Price Range$

For a deep dive into the best pizza joints around the country, check out our list of the best pizza in the world.

Reader Survey Poll Results

So, how did Harvest Pizzeria clinch the title? Well, it wasn’t just a random pick. We conducted a reader survey to find out which pizzeria truly deserves the crown of the best pizza in Columbus. And the results? Drumroll, please!

RankPizzeriaVotes (%)
1Harvest Pizzeria35%
2Fibonacci’s Pizzeria25%
3Borgata Pizza Cafe20%
4Hounddog’s Three Degree Pizza10%
5Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza5%
6Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery3%
7Paulie Gee’s2%

Yes, a whopping 35% of you pizza aficionados chose Harvest Pizzeria as your go-to slice of heaven. Fibonacci’s Pizzeria and Borgata Pizza Cafe were not far behind, though. For more on these amazing spots, take a look at our section on best pizza spots in Columbus.

If you’re curious about how Columbus pizza stands up against other cities, check out our guides on the best pizza in Brooklyn and the best pizza in Chicago.

So, there you have it, folks! Harvest Pizzeria is officially the best pizza in Columbus for 2022. Now, get out there and satisfy those pizza cravings!

Terita’s vs. The Pizza House

The Finalists

In the battle for the best pizza in Columbus, two pizzerias have risen to the top: Terita’s Pizza and The Pizza House. Terita’s Pizza has garnered significant acclaim, being voted by Dispatch readers as the Best Pizza in Columbus with 1,010 votes in the final round, surpassing The Pizza House which received 940 votes (The Columbus Dispatch). The competition involved 16 local pizzerias and restaurants, making it a fierce and mouth-watering contest.

Both Terita’s Pizza and The Pizza House offer a variety of mouth-watering options. Let’s break down some of their popular menu items and price points.

Menu ItemTerita’s PizzaThe Pizza House
Cheese Pizza (Large)$14.99$15.49
Pepperoni Pizza (Large)$16.99$16.49
Veggie Pizza (Large)$18.99$17.99
Meat Lover’s Pizza (Large)$19.99$19.49
Specialty Pizza$22.99$21.99

While the prices are fairly comparable, each pizzeria offers its own unique twist on classic favorites. Terita’s is known for its thinner-crusted, square-cut, edge-to-edge topped pizza, which has become a signature style in Columbus (The Columbus Dispatch).

If you’re curious about other amazing pizza spots, check out the best pizza in Brooklyn or the best pizza in Chicago.

Customer Reviews & Ratings

When it comes to customer reviews and ratings, both pizzerias have their loyal fan bases. Let’s take a look at the numbers.

PizzeriaYelp ReviewsAverage RatingPercentage of 5-Star Reviews
Terita’s Pizza1194.63 stars73%
The Pizza House2384.33 stars64%

Terita’s Pizza has an impressive average rating of 4.63 stars on Yelp, with over 73% of the reviews being five stars. In contrast, The Pizza House has a larger number of reviews but a slightly lower average rating of 4.33 stars, with nearly 64% of the ratings being five stars.

For those interested in exploring more pizza options, consider checking out the best pizza in Austin or the best pizza in Miami.

Ultimately, the choice between Terita’s Pizza and The Pizza House may come down to personal preference. Both offer delicious options that have earned them a spot at the top of Columbus’s pizza scene. Whether you’re a fan of thinner-crusted, square-cut pizza or prefer a more traditional approach, Columbus has a slice for everyone.

Columbus-Style Pizza

Characteristics

Columbus-Style Pizza is a unique gem in the world of pizza. If you haven’t tried it yet, you’re missing out on a slice of heaven. This pizza is baked on a thin crust, which gives it a delightful crunch with every bite. Unlike some pizzas that leave edges bare, Columbus-Style is covered edge-to-edge in toppings. That’s right, every single bite is a flavor explosion!

But wait, there’s more! Columbus-Style Pizza is cut into smaller squares rather than traditional pizza slices. Some call it “square cut,” others “party cut,” and a few fondly refer to it as “tavern cut.” Whatever you call it, these bite-sized pieces make it perfect for sharing at parties or just enjoying in a less messy, more manageable way.

FeatureDescription
CrustThin, crispy
ToppingsEdge-to-edge
Cut StyleSquare cut, party cut, tavern cut

Notable Columbus-Style Pizzerias

Now, where can you get your hands on this delightful pizza? Columbus is teeming with fantastic spots that serve this local specialty. Here are a few of my top picks that you absolutely must try:

  • Iacono’s
  • Rubino’s
  • Villa Nova Ristorante
  • Tommy’s Pizza
  • Pizza House
  • Massey’s Pizza
  • Donatos

These pizzerias are renowned for their take on Columbus-Style Pizza and offer a variety of toppings to satisfy your cravings. Each spot has its own unique twist, so it’s worth trying them all to find your favorite.

If you’re a pizza lover looking to explore more regional styles, don’t forget to check out our articles on the best pizza in chicago or the best pizza in brooklyn. And for those planning a trip, you might want to know about the best pizza in las vegas or even the best pizza in austin.

So, next time you’re in Columbus and your pizza cravings hit, you know exactly where to go for that perfect Columbus-Style Pizza experience. Enjoy your pizza adventure!

Other Regional Pizza Styles in Columbus

While Columbus has its own unique style of pizza, the city also boasts a variety of other regional pizza styles. Let’s dive into the delicious world of New York Style, Chicago Style Deep Dish, and Ohio Valley Style Pizza.

New York Style Pizza

Oh, New York Style Pizza – the big, floppy triangular slices that you can fold in half and eat on-the-go. In Columbus, you can find this iconic style at several spots. Mikey’s Late Night Slice and Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza serve up some of the best slices in town. These pizzerias have perfected the art of the thin, yet sturdy crust, topped with just the right amount of sauce and cheese.

PizzeriaLocationSpecialty
Mikey’s Late Night SliceVarious LocationsClassic NY Style Slices
Adriatico’sNeil Ave.Stuffed Crust NY Style

You can read more about the best pizza in Brooklyn if you ever find yourself craving the original.

Chicago Style Deep Dish

For those who like their pizza with a little more oomph, Columbus also caters to fans of Chicago Style Deep Dish. Picture this: a thick, buttery crust, layers of gooey cheese, and a chunky tomato sauce on top. Meister’s Bar in Grandview is a local favorite, known for their deep, cheesy pies that you can customize to your heart’s content.

PizzeriaLocationSpecialty
Meister’s BarGrandviewDeep Dish Build-Your-Own

Explore more about the best pizza in Chicago to see how it compares.

Ohio Valley Style Pizza

Ohio Valley Style Pizza, also known as Steubenville Style, is a unique pie that stands out. The pizza is baked with a layer of sauce and a dusting of cheese, but the magic happens after it comes out of the oven – an extra layer of cold cheese is added, giving it a distinctive texture and flavor. DiCarlo’s Pizza brings this Ohio Valley specialty to Columbus, offering a nostalgic taste for those who grew up with it.

PizzeriaLocationSpecialty
DiCarlo’s PizzaVarious LocationsSteubenville Style

For those who are curious, check out more regional favorites like the best pizza in Pittsburgh and see how Ohio Valley Style stacks up.

Columbus is a melting pot of pizza styles, offering something for every pizza lover. Whether you crave the giant slices of New York, the hearty deep dish of Chicago, or the unique taste of Ohio Valley, there’s a pie waiting for you. For more information on pizza varieties, don’t forget to visit our sections on Chicago Style Deep Dish and New York Style Pizza.