Best Pizza Spots in Colorado Springs

Looking for the best pizza in Colorado Springs? You’ve hit the jackpot. From classic Neapolitan to New York-style, this city has it all. Let’s explore some of the top-rated pizza joints and unique styles that make Colorado Springs a pizza lover’s dream.

Top-Rated Pizza Restaurants

According to Tripadvisor, the highest-rated pizza restaurant in Colorado Springs is Pizzeria Rustica. Known for its artisanal toppings and wood-fired delights, it’s a must-visit. Ranked 5th, Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana offers some of the best wood-fired pizza in town, with flavors that will make you question your loyalty to any other pizza place.

Here’s a table of some of the top-rated spots:

Pizza RestaurantRating (out of 5)
Pizzeria Rustica4.8
Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana4.7
Luigi’s Restaurant4.6
Old Chicago4.5
MOD Pizza4.4

For a more comprehensive list, check out Rocky Mountain Food Tours.

Unique Pizza Styles

Colorado Springs isn’t just about ratings; it’s about variety. Whether you crave a New York slice or a Neapolitan pie, there’s a style to suit every palate.

  1. New York Style: If oversized slices and thin, foldable crusts are your thing, then places like Fat Sully’s and Leon Gessi New York Pizza are your go-to spots. Leon Gessi has been serving up New York-style goodness since 1974, using fresh, homemade ingredients daily.

  2. Neapolitan: For those who love a chewy crust with a slightly charred bottom, Neapolitan pizzas at Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana and Pizzeria Rustica are a must-try. These places stick to the traditional methods, using wood-fired ovens to achieve that perfect balance of texture and flavor.

  3. Gourmet and Unique Creations: Slice 420 not only delivers oversized New York-style slices but also supports noble causes by donating a portion of their proceeds to children, veterans, and the sick (Rocky Mountain Food Tours). Then there’s White Pie, introducing New Haven style with unique offerings like their signature White Pie pizza made with crème fraîche, mushrooms, bacon, garlic, mozzarella, and a sunny-side-up egg in the center.

For more on these unique styles, check out our articles on best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Miami, and best pizza in Portland.

So next time you’re in Colorado Springs and have a pizza craving, you know where to head. Whether it’s the top-rated spots or the unique styles, this city has something to satisfy every pizza lover.

Pizzeria Rustica Experience

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Colorado Springs, Pizzeria Rustica is a must-visit spot. Nestled in Old Colorado City, this pizzeria is known for its authentic Neapolitan pies and exceptional attention to detail.

Neapolitan Pies and Artisanal Toppings

At Pizzeria Rustica, they don’t just make pizza—they craft it. The dough is a blend of imported Italian flour and organic Colorado whole wheat flour, resulting in a perfect, crisp-but-chewy crust. The selection of artisanal toppings is nothing short of a culinary masterpiece. Picture house-made cheese, oven-roasted tomatoes, artichokes, cremini mushrooms, and fresh basil dancing on your taste buds (Pikes Peak).

House-made CheeseFresh, creamy, and melts beautifully.
Oven-roasted TomatoesJuicy with a slight char, adding depth of flavor.
ArtichokesTender and earthy, perfect for a gourmet touch.
Cremini MushroomsRich and meaty, complementing the other toppings.
Fresh BasilAromatic and fresh, elevating every bite.

For those who love a good wine or beer with their pizza, Pizzeria Rustica offers an impressive selection at approachable prices. It’s the perfect place to indulge in a slice (or three) while enjoying a cozy atmosphere.

Wood-Fired Oven Delights

The magic behind the mouthwatering pizzas at Pizzeria Rustica lies in their wood-fired oven. Crafted by a local mason from Colorado Springs, this oven is the heart and soul of the pizzeria. The high temperatures and even heat distribution of the wood-fired oven create a pizza that’s crispy on the outside and delightfully soft on the inside (Rocky Mountain Food Tours).

Customers rave about the authenticity of the pizzas, often likening them to those found in Italy. The wood-fired technique imparts a unique smoky flavor that can’t be replicated by conventional ovens.

For pizza lovers seeking an unforgettable dining experience, Pizzeria Rustica is the place to be. Their dedication to traditional methods and high-quality ingredients ensures every slice is a slice of heaven. If you find yourself craving more pizza adventures, check out other top spots like the best pizza in Brooklyn or explore the best pizza in Manhattan.

Slice420 and Gourmet Pies

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Colorado Springs, Slice420 is a must-visit spot. They not only serve up delicious New York-style pizzas but also have a heartwarming mission of giving back to the community. Let’s dig into what makes Slice420 stand out.

High-Quality Ingredients and Philanthropy

Slice420 boasts gourmet pies stacked with meats and veggies on a delicious crust. The quality of the ingredients is evident with every bite. You can taste the freshness of the vegetables and the richness of the meats. It’s like a flavor explosion in your mouth.

But what really sets Slice420 apart is their commitment to philanthropy. They donate a portion of their proceeds to support children, veterans, and individuals relying on medical cannabis for critical health conditions. So, every time you indulge in a slice, you’re contributing to a noble cause. There’s nothing better than enjoying pizza and knowing you’re making a positive impact.

Oversized Slices and New York Style

Slice420 is known for their oversized slices that would make any New Yorker proud. These slices are so big, you might need two hands to handle them. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, providing the ideal base for the generous toppings.

Slice SizeOversized
CrustThin and crispy
StyleNew York

The New York style is evident in every aspect of their pizza. From the hand-tossed dough to the gooey cheese and perfect balance of toppings, it’s like a little slice of New York right here in Colorado Springs. For more on this style, you can check out our guide to the best pizza in Brooklyn.

If you haven’t tried Slice420 yet, you’re missing out. Their combination of high-quality ingredients, philanthropic efforts, and mouthwatering New York-style pizza makes them a standout in the Colorado Springs pizza scene. So, grab a slice, support a good cause, and enjoy some of the best pizza around.

For more pizza adventures, explore the best pizza in Chicago or find out where to get the best pizza in Austin.

Basil & Barley’s Crafted Pizzas

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Colorado Springs, Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana is a strong contender. This pizzeria, located in Briargate, is known for its dedication to the art of Neapolitan pizza making.

Neapolitan Dough Perfection

At Basil & Barley, they take their dough very seriously. They follow precise specifications for kneading, resting, and stretching the dough before baking it in a 1,000-degree oven imported straight from Naples, Italy (Springs Mag). This dedication to traditional methods results in a crust that’s both chewy and crispy, a hallmark of Neapolitan-style pizza.

I couldn’t resist diving into a classic Margherita pizza. The fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomato sauce were perfectly balanced on that impeccable crust. Here’s a quick look at the numbers:

Pizza TypeOven TemperatureDough Resting Time
Neapolitan1,000°F24 hours

Gluten-Free and Signature Pies

For those with dietary restrictions, Basil & Barley offers a gluten-free crust option that doesn’t sacrifice taste or texture (Rocky Mountain Food Tours). They also have crusts featuring USA organic charcoal powder for an added twist.

Their menu is a playground for pizza lovers, with a variety of signature pies that go beyond the traditional. One of my personal favorites is the “Diavola,” which features spicy salami, fresh mozzarella, and a kick of red pepper flakes.

Pizza TypeGluten-Free OptionSignature Pies
NeapolitanYesDiavola, Truffle Funghi

Basil & Barley is not just about great pizza; it’s about the experience. Each bite takes you on a journey to Naples, without the need for a passport. If you’re a pizza enthusiast, this spot should be at the top of your list.

Don’t forget to check out other top-rated pizza joints in different cities if you ever find yourself traveling. You can explore the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, or even the best pizza in Boston.

Louie’s Pizza and Hometown Feel

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Colorado Springs, Louie’s Pizza stands out with its hometown charm and delectable offerings. This local chain, with five locations across the city, has become a favorite among residents and visitors alike.

Chewy Crust and Abundant Toppings

Louie’s Pizza is known for its chewy crust that provides the perfect base for a plethora of toppings. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or prefer a more adventurous combination, Louie’s has got you covered. The crust is just the right amount of chewy without being too dense, making every bite a delightful experience (Pikes Peak).

The toppings at Louie’s are nothing short of abundant. They don’t skimp on the good stuff, ensuring that each slice is loaded with flavor. From fresh vegetables to high-quality meats, the ingredients are always top-notch. It’s no wonder that pizza lovers flock to this spot for their fix of cheesy goodness.

CrustChewy and perfectly balanced
ToppingsPlentiful and high-quality
Locations5 across Colorado Springs

Dessert Delights and Cozy Atmosphere

But wait, there’s more! Louie’s Pizza isn’t just about savory pies. They also offer a unique dessert pizza called La Fruita Pizza. This sweet treat features a fruit topping on a cinnamon crust, providing a delightful end to your meal.

The cozy atmosphere at Louie’s Pizza adds to the overall dining experience. Whether you’re dining in or opting for delivery, the friendly staff and welcoming environment make you feel right at home. It’s the kind of place where you can kick back, relax, and enjoy a great meal with family and friends.

For more hidden gems and pizza spots across the country, check out our articles on the best pizza in chicago and the best pizza in brooklyn. If you’re ever in the area, don’t miss out on the best pizza in boston or the best pizza in houston.

Visiting Louie’s Pizza is like stepping into a slice of heaven right here in Colorado Springs. With their chewy crust, abundant toppings, and mouthwatering dessert options, it’s no wonder they’ve earned a spot on the list of the best pizza in town.

Fat Sully’s NY Pizza

Fat Sully’s NY Pizza is the place to be if you’re a pizza lover in Colorado Springs. This joint serves up some of the best New York style pizza in the area, and it’s perfect for anyone craving a big, cheesy slice of heaven. Here’s what you need to know about this pizza paradise.

Giant Pies and Affordable Slices

At Fat Sully’s, size matters. They offer giant 26″ pies that are ideal for sharing with friends or family, but if you’re flying solo, don’t worry—they’ve got you covered with affordable pizza by the slice. Each slice costs under $5 with an additional $0.70 per topping, making it a great stop for a post-soccer dinner or pre-museum lunch.

Slice of Pizza$5
Additional Topping$0.70
Loaded Meat Slice$6

Their Hellfire pizza and Hellfire calzones are not for the faint of heart, adding extra spice to your life without burning a hole in your wallet (Pikes Peak). And if you’re a fan of great beer, Fat Sully’s has a fantastic selection on tap, making it easier to wash down those spicy bites (Yelp).

Red & White Sauce Options

Fat Sully’s offers both red and white sauce options for their pizzas, allowing you to customize your pie to your heart’s content. Whether you’re a traditionalist who loves a classic marinara or someone who prefers a creamy white sauce, they’ve got something for everyone.

For those who like to mix things up, you can even go half-and-half to get the best of both worlds. Pairing these options with their high-quality ingredients ensures that every bite is bursting with flavor.

If you’re still on the hunt for the best pizza in other cities, check out our guides for the best pizza in chicago, best pizza in brooklyn, and even the best pizza in the world. But for now, if you’re in Colorado Springs, Fat Sully’s NY Pizza should be at the top of your list.