Pizza Paradise in Cincinnati

Slice of Cincinnati’s Pizza Scene

Ah, Cincinnati. Known for its chili, but let’s not forget the pizza! If you’re anything like me, the hunt for the best pizza in Cincinnati is a never-ending adventure. From thick, cheesy slices to gourmet toppings, Cincinnati’s pizza scene is as diverse as it is delicious.

Must-Try Pizzerias in Cincinnati

If you haven’t yet embarked on a pizza pilgrimage around Cincinnati, let me be your guide. Here’s a list of must-try pizzerias that promise to tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more.

PizzeriaSpecialtyNotable Mention
Strong’s Brick Oven PizzeriaWood-fired pizzaRustic and authentic flavors
Fireside PizzaClassic and innovative piesCozy ambiance
Dewey’s PizzaVariety of toppingsFamily-friendly atmosphere
Zip’s CafeOld-school charmClassic American pizza
Scotti’s Italian EateryTraditional ItalianRich history
Pompilio’sHomestyle pizzaFamous for its sauce
St. Francis ApizzaNeapolitan stylePerfect crust
A TavolaNeapolitan delightsCrunchy-yet-fluffy crust
Mikey’s Late Night SliceLate-night cravingsFunky and fun vibe
Chicago Gyro Pizza at Mac’s Pizza PubUnique fusionBest Pizza Pub in the Tristate area

For detailed recommendations on other cities, check out our articles on the best pizza in Chicago, best pizza in Brooklyn, and best pizza in Boston.

Each of these pizzerias brings something unique to the table, whether it’s the wood-fired goodness at Strong’s Brick Oven Pizzeria or the late-night vibe at Mikey’s Late Night Slice. And let’s not forget the hidden gems like Zip’s Cafe and Scotti’s Italian Eatery, which offer a slice of history along with your pizza.

If you’re looking for more pizza recommendations across the country, explore our articles on the best pizza in Houston and best pizza in Las Vegas. For those planning a pizza road trip, don’t miss the best pizza in Portland or the best pizza in Austin.

Whether you’re a fan of Neapolitan crusts, Chicago-style deep dish, or something entirely unique like the Chicago Gyro Pizza at Mac’s Pizza Pub, Cincinnati has got you covered. So grab a slice, or maybe ten, and dive into the cheesy, saucy goodness that makes Cincinnati’s pizza scene truly exceptional.

Top Picks by CityBeat

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Cincinnati, I’ve got you covered. CityBeat, Cincinnati’s go-to source for all things food, has highlighted some top-notch pizzerias that you simply can’t miss. Let’s dive into their top picks and see what makes these spots so special.

Strong’s Brick Oven Pizzeria

Strong’s Brick Oven Pizzeria is an absolute gem. CityBeat lists it as one of the essential pizzerias in Cincinnati (CityBeat). The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza. Their brick oven pizzas have this incredible crust that’s crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside. And let’s not even get started on their toppings—they’re on point!

Pizza TypePrice ($)Rating (out of 5)
Margherita124.5
Pepperoni144.7
Four Cheese154.6

If you haven’t been to Strong’s yet, drop everything and get there. It’s a pizza experience you won’t regret.

Fireside Pizza

Next up, we’ve got Fireside Pizza, another CityBeat favorite (CityBeat). This place is not just about great pizza; it’s an experience. Located in an old firehouse, the ambiance is as hot as their oven. Their wood-fired pizzas are legendary, with a smoky flavor that’ll make your taste buds dance.

Pizza TypePrice ($)Rating (out of 5)
Classic Cheese104.3
BBQ Chicken164.8
Veggie Delight144.5

For a slice that’s both delicious and unique, Fireside Pizza is where you need to be. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

Dewey’s Pizza

Last but certainly not least is Dewey’s Pizza, another top pick by CityBeat. Dewey’s is known for its creative and flavorful pizzas that never disappoint. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or something more adventurous, Dewey’s has got you covered.

Pizza TypePrice ($)Rating (out of 5)
Hawaiian134.4
Meat Lovers174.7
Southwest BBQ Chicken164.6

Dewey’s is perfect for those who love a good twist on traditional pizza. Each bite is a burst of flavor that you won’t want to miss.

For more pizza adventures, check out our guides to the best pizza in New York, the best pizza in Chicago, and the best pizza in Portland. Happy pizza hunting!

Hidden Gems and Classics

Cincinnati’s pizza scene is packed with hidden gems and classic spots that every pizza lover must try. Here are three of my favorites that offer some of the best pizza in Cincinnati.

Zip’s Cafe

Zip’s Cafe is a true gem in the heart of Cincinnati. Being one of the oldest restaurants in Greater Cincinnati, it offers a cozy, old-school atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. The pizza here is nothing short of legendary. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are always fresh. If you’re ever in town, make sure to grab a slice—or ten.

FeatureDetails
Location1036 Delta Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45208
SpecialtyClassic Pepperoni
AtmosphereCozy, Old-School

Scotti’s Italian Eatery

Scotti’s Italian Eatery is another must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts. This place has been serving up delicious pies for decades and is known for its authentic Italian flavors (CityBeat). Their margherita pizza is a crowd favorite, with a perfect balance of fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil. Trust me, one bite and you’ll be hooked.

FeatureDetails
Location919 Vine St, Cincinnati, OH 45202
SpecialtyMargherita Pizza
AtmosphereAuthentic, Italian Charm

Pompilio’s

Pompilio’s is a classic Italian restaurant that offers some of the best pizza in Cincinnati. This historic eatery has been around for ages and is beloved by locals and visitors alike (CityBeat). Their wood-fired pizzas are a must-try, with a perfect blend of smoky flavor and delicious toppings. Make sure to pair your pizza with one of their signature cocktails for a complete dining experience.

FeatureDetails
Location600 Washington Ave, Newport, KY 41071
SpecialtyWood-Fired Pizza
AtmosphereHistoric, Classic Italian

For more pizza recommendations across the country, check out our guides on the best pizza in Brooklyn, best pizza in Chicago, and best pizza in Austin.

CityBeat Staff and Readers’ Favorites

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Cincinnati, CityBeat staff and readers have spoken. Here are their top picks:

St. Francis Apizza

St. Francis Apizza is hailed as one of the best pizza joints in Cincinnati by CityBeat staff and readers (CityBeat). This place is a slice of heaven! Picture this: a crispy crust, bubbling cheese, and toppings so fresh you’d think they were picked straight from a garden. Their menu is like a love letter to pizza lovers, with options ranging from classic Margherita to inventive combinations that make your taste buds do a happy dance.

If you’re a pizza purist or an adventurous eater, St. Francis Apizza has something for everyone. Just remember, sharing is caring, but when it comes to their pies, you might not want to!

A Tavola

A Tavola is ranked as the top pizza parlor in Cincinnati, and trust me, it’s worth all the hype. Known for its wood-fired Neapolitan-style crust and unique specialty pies, A Tavola encourages sharing multiple pies so you can savor a variety of flavors.

Imagine biting into a pizza with a perfectly blistered crust, just the right amount of char, and toppings that make you want to shout, “Mamma Mia!” Their menu boasts a wide range of options, from the simple yet divine Margherita to the more adventurous Fig & Prosciutto. It’s the kind of place where you walk in hungry and leave with a heart full of pizza joy.

Mikey’s Late Night Slice

Mikey’s Late Night Slice is another gem in Cincinnati’s pizza crown, as chosen by CityBeat staff and readers (CityBeat). This place is not just a pizzeria; it’s an experience. Open late and ready to satisfy your midnight cravings, Mikey’s serves up slices that are as big as your head and as delicious as your wildest pizza dreams.

Their menu is a playground of flavors, with options like the “Cheezus Crust” and “Spicy-Ass Pepperoni” that promise to tickle your taste buds. Mikey’s is the perfect spot for a post-night-out snack or a casual hangout with friends. Just be prepared to fall in love with every bite.

If you ever find yourself wandering the streets of Cincinnati with a pizza craving, these spots are sure to hit the mark. And if you’re curious about the best pizza in other cities, we’ve got you covered. Check out our guides to the best pizza in Brooklyn, best pizza in Boston, and more!

Unique Pizza Experiences

When I think about the best pizza in Cincinnati, Mac’s Pizza Pub always comes to mind. Their unique offerings and delightful ambiance make every visit a memorable experience.

Chicago Gyro Pizza at Mac’s Pizza Pub

First up, the legendary Chicago Gyro Pizza. This pizza is not just a meal; it’s a culinary adventure. Voted the Best Entrée at Taste of Cincinnati in 2010 and the second-best in the Midwest in NAPICS 2011, this pizza is a crowd favorite (Mac’s Pizza Pub). Topped with gyro meat, tzatziki sauce, tomatoes, onions, and a blend of cheeses, this pizza is a must-try.

PizzaAwards
Chicago Gyro PizzaBest Entrée at Taste of Cincinnati (2010), Second-best in Midwest (NAPICS 2011)

Specialty Menu at Mac’s Pizza Pub

Mac’s Pizza Pub doesn’t just stop at pizzas. Their specialty menu is a treasure trove of deliciousness. From hand-crafted burgers to artisan sandwiches and hand-spun chicken wings, there’s something for everyone. They pride themselves on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients, making their dough fresh in-house daily, grinding their cheese blend daily, and cutting vegetables in-house (Mac’s Pizza Pub).

  • Hand-crafted burgers
  • Artisan sandwiches
  • Hand-spun chicken wings
  • Delectable appetizers

For those looking for unique culinary experiences, Mac’s Pizza Pub offers a variety of menu items that go beyond the usual pizza offerings. It’s a great place to explore different tastes and flavors.

Locations and Ambiance at Mac’s Pizza Pub

Mac’s Pizza Pub has multiple locations across the Tristate area, including Clifton, Wooster Pike, Landen, Blue Ash, Mainstrasse, and Cold Spring. Each location offers a cozy and welcoming ambiance, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or family.

LocationAmbiance
CliftonCozy and welcoming
Wooster PikeFamily-friendly
LandenCasual and relaxed
Blue AshVibrant and lively
MainstrasseTrendy and hip
Cold SpringWarm and inviting

Whether you’re in the mood for a quiet dinner or a lively night out, Mac’s Pizza Pub has the perfect spot for you. Their commitment to quality and unique experiences makes them a standout in Cincinnati’s pizza scene. Don’t forget to check out their specialty pizzas and other delicious menu items.

For more about the best pizza in the world or to explore other cities like best pizza in chicago, visit our dedicated pizza sections.

Cincinnati Magazine’s Recommendations

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Cincinnati, I, your pizza-loving guide, have scoured the city and uncovered some true gems. Here are Cincinnati Magazine’s top picks that will make you drool.

A Tavola’s Neapolitan Delights

A Tavola is Cincinnati’s crown jewel for Neapolitan pizza lovers. The crust is a perfect balance of crunchy and fluffy, making each bite a heavenly experience (Cincinnati Magazine). Their specialty pies range from classic Margherita to inventive creations that will have you coming back for more.

Specialty PiePrice ($)
Margherita14
Fig & Prosciutto16
Brussels Sprouts & Pancetta15

Two Cities Pizza’s Style Fusion

Two Cities Pizza brings a delightful clash of Chicago and New York right to Mason. Whether you’re in the mood for a thick, buttery Chicago-style pie or a chewy, foldable New York slice, they’ve got you covered. It’s like having two cities’ best pizzas under one roof.

Pizza StyleCrust TypePrice Range ($)
Chicago-StyleThick & Buttery18 – 25
New York-StyleChewy15 – 20

Camporosso’s Wood-Fired Artisan Pizzas

For those who crave artisanal flavors, Camporosso in Ft. Mitchell is a must-visit. Their wood-fired pizzas boast a crispy crust and toppings that are nothing short of extraordinary. The meat-lovers pizza, with its charred pepperoni, sopressata salami, sausage, and applewood-smoked bacon, is a carnivore’s dream come true.

Artisan PizzaPrice ($)
Meat-Lovers18
Margherita14
White Pizza16

For those who can’t get enough of pizza, don’t forget to check out the best pizza in chicago, best pizza in brooklyn, and best pizza in boston. Each city offers its own unique twist on this beloved dish. Happy eating!